
Reach for this book when you have a child who finds standard math drills boring but loves a good mystery or a verbal challenge. Written by the author of Alice in Wonderland, this collection of ten knots uses whimsical short stories to present complex mathematical and logical puzzles. It is a brilliant tool for children who have outgrown simple riddles and are ready to apply their reasoning skills to real world, albeit quirky, scenarios. The tone is Victorian and witty, which encourages a child to slow down and read carefully. Beyond the math, the book fosters resilience and a growth mindset. Carroll includes an appendix where he reviews solutions from original readers, often with sharp humor. This helps children see that even adults make mistakes in logic, and that the process of solving a problem is just as important as the answer itself. It is best suited for children ages 10 and up who enjoy a cerebral challenge.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe book is entirely secular and focuses on intellectual exercise. There are no heavy themes like death or trauma. Some modern readers may find Carroll's 19th-century 'acerbic' wit slightly biting, but it is directed at logical errors rather than individuals.
A middle schooler who is gifted in math but perhaps disengaged from schoolwork, or a child who loves wordplay, puns, and the 'escape room' style of thinking. It is perfect for the student who asks, 'When will I ever use this?'
Parents should be aware of the Victorian vocabulary, which may require some explanation for younger readers. Reading the solution appendix beforehand is helpful to guide the child without giving away the answer. A parent might notice their child finishing math homework too quickly and feeling bored, or a child expressing frustration that math feels like 'just numbers' without any story or life to it.
Younger readers (10-12) will enjoy the funny stories and simpler logic puzzles, while older teens will appreciate the complex algebra and the dry, sophisticated humor in Carroll's critiques.
Unlike modern puzzle books, this is high literature. It combines the surrealist charm of Wonderland with rigorous mathematical theory, making it a rare bridge between the humanities and STEM.
The book is structured into ten short stories, or knots, each containing a mathematical problem embedded in a narrative. These range from logic puzzles involving knights and liars to algebraic questions about speeds, ages, and geometric arrangements. The second half of the book is a detailed appendix where Carroll provides solutions and critiques the attempts of 19th-century readers.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.