
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is navigating the isolating and non-linear journey of grief, particularly following the sudden loss of a sibling or peer. It is a profound resource for a teen who feels 'stuck' in their mourning or is struggling with the foggy, fragmented memories that often accompany trauma. The story follows Leo during the first year after her sister Nina's death, utilizing a unique reverse-chronological structure that mirrors the way we often look backward to make sense of the present. While the book deals with heavy themes of loss, guilt, and the revelation of secrets, it remains grounded in a realistic, secular perspective that prioritizes emotional honesty over easy answers. It is most appropriate for high schoolers (ages 14+) due to its sophisticated narrative structure and the maturity of its emotional exploration. Parents might choose this title because it validates that there is no 'correct' timeline for healing and provides a bridge for discussing the complicated feelings of anger and loyalty that arise after a tragedy.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewDeep exploration of grief, depression, and the physical/emotional toll of losing a loved one.
Underage drinking is discussed as a factor leading up to the accident.
Complicated romantic feelings and physical closeness between grieving characters.
Characters keep secrets about the accident to protect themselves or the memory of the deceased.
The book deals directly with accidental death, grief, and survivor's guilt. The approach is realistic and secular, focusing on psychological processing and family dynamics rather than spiritual explanations. The resolution is hopeful but grounded, emphasizing that while the pain doesn't disappear, it becomes manageable.
A 16-year-old who is perhaps acting out or withdrawing after a loss. This reader is likely frustrated by people telling them to 'move on' and needs a book that honors the messy, long-term nature of sibling loss.
Parents should be aware that the book moves backward in time, which can be disorienting. They may want to discuss the depictions of underage drinking and the legal consequences of the accident mentioned throughout. A parent might notice their teen becoming obsessed with the details of a past event or forming an intense, potentially unhealthy bond with someone else who shared the trauma.
Younger teens (14) will focus on the mystery of the accident and the 'forbidden' friendship with East. Older teens (17-18) will likely resonate more with the existential weight of identity loss when a sibling dies.
The reverse-chronological structure is the standout feature. By moving backward, Benway forces the reader to experience the 'why' after seeing the 'what,' which perfectly captures the obsessive nature of trauma-induced memory.
The narrative unfolds in reverse, starting one year after the death of Nina and moving backward toward the night of the car accident. Leo, the younger sister, is drowning in grief and memory loss regarding the event. She forms a complex bond with East, Nina's boyfriend, who was driving the car. As they move closer to the truth of that night, Leo must reconcile her idolized image of her sister with the reality of who Nina actually was.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.