
Reach for this book when your child is struggling with the delayed or messy reality of grief, particularly the realization that family members process loss at different speeds. While many books focus on the immediate aftermath of death, this story explores the 'long tail' of mourning through twins Abby and Anna Stevenson. Three years after their father's death, a school project triggers a deep rift between the sisters: one wants to remember, while the other is desperate to move on. It is a compassionate look at sibling conflict, the Jewish traditions of mourning, and the importance of emotional honesty. This middle-grade novel is ideal for children ages 8 to 12 who feel 'stuck' in their feelings or who are frustrated by a sibling's different reaction to a shared family hardship.
The book deals directly with the death of a parent. It is a secular approach but deeply rooted in Jewish cultural identity and the specific ways the family honors their father's memory. The resolution is realistic: they don't stop missing him, but they learn to respect each other's boundaries in how they grieve.





















Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewA middle-schooler who lost a loved one years ago and is confused by why they are suddenly feeling 'sad all over again' or why their siblings seem to care less (or more) than they do.
Read the scenes where the girls visit the cemetery. It is a poignant moment that may require conversation about your own family's rituals for honoring the deceased. A parent might see their children having explosive, seemingly 'unreasonable' fights that are actually rooted in suppressed memories or shared trauma.
Younger readers will focus on the 'twin fight' and the babysitting subplots. Older readers will resonate with the complex psychological concept of 'anniversary reactions' to grief.
Unlike many grief books that focus on the funeral, this explores the 'years later' reality of being a single-parent family and how identity is shaped by what we choose to remember or forget.
Abby and Anna Stevenson are identical twins and members of the Baby-Sitters Club. Their father died in a car accident several years prior to the series start. When their teacher assigns a 'Heritage and Family' project, the girls' different coping mechanisms clash. Abby wants to celebrate her father's memory and their Jewish heritage, while Anna becomes withdrawn and irritable, seemingly wanting to erase the past. The tension escalates into a major sibling rift that affects their schoolwork and their roles in the BSC.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.