
Reach for this book when your child starts noticing that an older relative has a prickly exterior or behaviors that seem out of sync with the modern world. It is a gentle tool for teaching that every person carries an invisible history that shapes who they are today. Through a simple walk for groceries in New York, the story unspools a grandmother's past as a Jewish refugee fleeing Nazi Germany, explaining her frugality and sharp edges with deep empathy. While it touches on the Holocaust and loss, the focus remains on the bond between an eleven year old boy and his grandmother. It is perfectly suited for children aged 8 to 12 who are beginning to navigate complex family dynamics and historical legacies. Parents will appreciate how the watercolor art uses color to distinguish between the drab present and the vibrant, albeit painful, memories of the past.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewDepicts historical antisemitism and the exclusion of Jewish people in Nazi Germany.
Characters must flee their homes to escape persecution.
The book deals directly with the Holocaust, antisemitism, and the refugee experience. These themes are handled with historical honesty but are framed through the lens of memory. The resolution is realistic and bittersweet: the past cannot be changed, but Benji's understanding of it creates a hopeful shift in their relationship.
An observant 10-year-old who has wondered why a grandparent acts 'differently' or is 'always grumpy,' and who is ready to understand that adults were once children with their own joys and fears.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the basic historical context of WWII and why Jewish families had to leave Germany. The transition between color (past) and monochrome (present) is a great talking point. A child expressing frustration or lack of respect for an elderly relative, or a child asking, 'Why is Grandma so mean to the cashier?'
Younger readers will focus on the 'treasure hunt' for food and the cool art. Older readers will grasp the emotional weight of the 'Alte Zachen' (old things) metaphor and the lasting impact of trauma.
The use of color is masterful: the present is depicted in muted, almost clinical tones, while the past is lush and saturated, brilliantly subverting the trope that the past was 'black and white.'
Benji, an 11-year-old boy, spends a day traversing New York City with his grandmother, Bubbe Rosa, to gather ingredients for Shabbat dinner. As they visit various shops, Rosa's impatient and frugal behavior is juxtaposed with vibrant watercolor flashbacks of her childhood in Berlin, her experience as a refugee, and a lost teenage romance. The day culminates in a family dinner where Benji sees his grandmother in a new, more compassionate light.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.