
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is grappling with the heavy weight of a complicated loss or struggling with the silence that follows a traumatic event. It is particularly suited for teens who feel isolated by their grief or who express themselves more deeply through creative outlets like poetry. The story follows seventeen year old Emily, who is sent to an Amherst boarding school after the tragic suicide of her ex boyfriend. Through her discovery of Emily Dickinson and the rhythmic process of writing her own verse, she navigates intense feelings of guilt and shame. This is a mature, reflective read that addresses the messy reality of healing. Parents might choose this book to help their child see that they are not alone in their darkest moments and to provide a literary bridge for discussing difficult topics like mental health and forgiveness. It is most appropriate for high school students due to its sophisticated themes and honest depiction of emotional trauma.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThemes of grief, guilt, and the aftermath of trauma are heavy throughout.
Contains profanity appropriate for a realistic high school setting.
Discusses a past sexual relationship and the resulting pregnancy/abortion.
The book deals directly and intensely with suicide, grief, and teen pregnancy. The approach is secular and deeply psychological, focusing on the internal landscape of the survivor. The resolution is realistic and hopeful, focusing on the possibility of continuing to live rather than a neat or happy ending.
A thoughtful, literary teenager who is going through a period of isolation or mourning. This is for the student who finds solace in the library or creative writing and needs a mirror for their own complex, non linear healing process.
Parents should be aware of the descriptions of the suicide and the mention of an abortion. It is best to read this alongside the teen or be ready for deep conversations about mental health and the pressure of young relationships. A parent might notice their child becoming withdrawn, obsessively writing in a journal, or expressing deep feelings of responsibility for things beyond their control.
Younger teens (14) may focus more on the mystery of Emily's past, while older teens (17 to 18) will likely connect with the nuanced themes of identity and the redemptive power of art.
Unlike many YA novels about suicide, this book uses the historical figure of Emily Dickinson as a tangible anchor, making the process of healing feel connected to a larger literary tradition.
After her former boyfriend commits suicide in the school locker room, Emily is sent to an Amherst boarding school for a fresh start. The narrative is split between traditional prose and Emily's own poetry as she unspools the history of their relationship, her pregnancy, and the crushing guilt she carries. While at school, she finds a deep connection to the poet Emily Dickinson, whose presence in the town helps her find a path toward self forgiveness.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.