
Reach for this book when your older teenager feels disconnected from their family history or is struggling to reconcile their cultural heritage with their current surroundings. It is a powerful choice for families navigating the complexities of the immigrant experience, specifically for those who feel like outsiders in their own homes. This literary mystery follows two sisters: Masha, who found her identity in Israel, and Anna, who feels trapped in Milwaukee. When Anna disappears after being contacted by a mysterious figure from their Soviet past, Masha must return home to find her. The story explores themes of loneliness, sibling bonds, and the search for belonging against the backdrop of the 2008 recession. It is a sophisticated, emotionally resonant read for older teens (15+) that normalizes the messy feelings of finding one's place in the world.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThemes of displacement, loneliness, and family trauma.
Characters engage in deception and must navigate complex ethical choices.
Exploration of attraction and emotional manipulation.
Brief mentions of drinking or smoking in a college/bohemian setting.
The book deals with identity, extortion, and family trauma through a secular Jewish lens. The approach is direct and realistic, capturing the grit of the 2008 recession and the vulnerability of young adults seeking connection. The resolution is realistic and transformative rather than purely 'happy.'
A high school junior or senior who feels like a 'black sheep' or is fascinated by family genealogy and the secrets parents keep. It will especially resonate with first or second-generation immigrants.
Parents should be aware of themes involving financial desperation and the influence of manipulative older figures (the 'grifter'). The book is best for readers who can handle non-linear timelines and mature emotional themes. A parent might see their teen becoming increasingly secretive, pulling away from family traditions, or expressing a deep desire to leave their hometown behind.
Younger teens (15) will focus on the suspense and Anna's rebellion. Older teens (18) will likely connect more with Masha's perspective on the permanent weight of the past and the difficulty of defining 'home.'
Unlike many immigrant stories that focus on the initial arrival, this focuses on the 'after-effects' across different generations of sisters, specifically within the unique context of the Russian-Jewish diaspora in the American Midwest.
Set in 2008 Milwaukee, the story alternates between Anna, a restless college student and artist who feels stifled by her immigrant parents, and Masha, her older sister who has built a life in Israel. Anna is lured into a dangerous situation by a stranger claiming to be a long-lost sister and a charismatic grifter. When Anna disappears, Masha returns to their childhood home to reconstruct Anna's final steps, forced to confront the family secrets and personal demons they both tried to outrun.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.