For the child who dreams of making their mark and finding their place, this graphic novel celebrates courage, talent, and proving yourself in unexpected ways.
A parent might reach for this book when their child feels underestimated or is searching for a unique way to prove their talent. Set in the Old West, this graphic novel tells the story of Phoebe Moses, a young Black girl with an incredible talent for sharpshooting. To compete in a world that doesn't believe a girl can be the best, she creates a secret identity. The story explores themes of self-confidence, perseverance, and challenging stereotypes. Perfect for readers aged 8 to 12, this book is an empowering and visually engaging way to show a child that true skill knows no gender or race, and that courage means being yourself.
Gun use is a core part of the story (sharpshooting), but it is framed as a skill and sport.
Sensitive Topics
The book directly addresses historical sexism and racism in an age-appropriate way. Phoebe is barred from competition for being a girl, and as a Black protagonist in the Old West, she operates within a world of prejudice. The approach is straightforward, showing these as obstacles to be overcome. The resolution is hopeful, as Phoebe's talent and courage earn her respect, proving her doubters wrong.
Ideal Reader
This is for the 9 to 11-year-old who loves an underdog story, especially a child who feels their own unique talents are overlooked or misunderstood. It's perfect for fans of historical fiction and adventure who are just getting into graphic novels, particularly for readers who are looking for strong, capable female protagonists.
Parent Prep
No specific pages need previewing, but parents can enrich the experience by being ready to talk about the historical context. A brief conversation about the real Nat Love or life in the Old West, including the roles of women and Black Americans, can provide valuable context. The book can be read cold but is enhanced with discussion. The parent has heard their child say something like, "They said I can't do that, it's for boys," or has seen their child lose confidence in a hobby because they don't fit the typical mold of who participates.
Age Experience
A younger reader (8-9) will latch onto the exciting plot: the disguise, the competition, and the clear 'good guy vs. bad guy' dynamic. An older reader (10-12) will better appreciate the nuances of the historical context, the themes of sexism and racism, the development of Phoebe's friendship with Nat, and the deeper message about forging your own identity.
What Makes It Special
Unlike many historical fiction books for this age, its graphic novel format makes the era incredibly dynamic and accessible. Its greatest strength is placing a young, Black female protagonist at the center of a Western, a genre that has traditionally excluded such voices. This fresh perspective is both important and highly entertaining.
Read plot summary
In the 1800s American West, young Phoebe Moses is a sharpshooting prodigy. When a local competition bans girls from entering, she creates a disguise and a new name: the Best Shot in the West. With the help of her family and a new, skeptical friend, the famous stagecoach driver Nat Love, Phoebe navigates the contest, facing down rivals and challenging everyone's expectations about who a hero can be. This historical fiction adventure is a fictionalized account inspired by real figures.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Discussion Prompts
1
Phoebe had to create the secret identity 'Best Shot' to enter the competition. Why do you think she did that? Have you ever felt like you had to hide a part of yourself to do something you wanted?
2
Nat Love didn't believe in Phoebe at first, but he became her biggest supporter. What specific moments changed his mind? What does this story show us about being a true friend?
3
At the end, Phoebe reveals who she really is. Do you think this was a brave choice? What might have happened if she had kept her identity a secret?
4
The book is set in the 'Old West.' How was life different for a girl like Phoebe back then compared to today? What challenges did she face that you don't?
