
Reach for this book when your child is struggling to accept a new reality following a parental separation or a sudden move. It is particularly effective for children who are stuck in the bargaining phase of grief, secretly wishing they could wish away their problems or go back to how things used to be. The story follows twelve-year-old Rebecca, who is uprooted to her grandmother's house after her parents split. There, she discovers a magic bread box that grants any wish, provided the item fits inside. While it seems like a solution to her unhappiness, the magic comes with unforeseen consequences and ethical dilemmas. This is a sophisticated blend of contemporary realism and low fantasy that helps children aged 8 to 12 process the complex feelings of powerlessness and the realization that some things, like a parent's happiness or a broken marriage, cannot be fixed with a simple wish. It provides a safe space to discuss the difference between what we want and what we truly need to heal.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe protagonist uses magic to 'take' things that belong to others, leading to guilt.
Some moments of tension regarding the magic's source and the feeling of being haunted.
The book deals directly with divorce, parental conflict, and the emotional fallout of relocation. The approach is a mix of grounded realism and metaphorical fantasy. The resolution is realistic rather than a fairy-tale ending; the parents do not reunite, but Rebecca finds a path toward acceptance and genuine connection. It is a secular narrative focused on emotional intelligence.
A middle-schooler who feels like their life is being decided by adults and is harboring a deep, secret fantasy that their parents might get back if only they were better or if luck changed. It is perfect for the child who enjoys the magic of Edward Eager but needs the emotional honesty of a modern divorce story.
Parents should be aware that Rebecca essentially steals items via the bread box, which leads to significant guilt. One specific scene involves her wishing for her father, which results in a confusing and emotionally taxing encounter that highlights the limits of her power. A parent might choose this after hearing their child express a desperate wish for things to go back to the way they were, or if the child is struggling to make friends in a new environment after a family split.
Younger readers (age 8-9) will focus on the thrill of the magical bread box and the fun of the wishes. Older readers (11-12) will better grasp the metaphor of the box as a coping mechanism and the heavy ethical weight of Rebecca's choices.
Unlike many books about divorce that stay strictly in the realm of realism, this uses the 'careful what you wish for' trope to explore the internal life of a child in crisis. It avoids easy answers, acknowledging that some pains are bigger than magic.
After her parents separate, Rebecca is moved from Baltimore to her grandmother's attic in Atlanta. Feeling lonely and resentful, she discovers an old bread box that can conjure anything she wishes for, as long as it fits inside. She uses the box to win friends and find comfort, but the magic begins to feel like stealing, and she eventually realizes that no amount of conjured items can force her parents back together.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.