
A parent might reach for this book when they want to celebrate family traditions and show a child that mistakes are just part of learning. This heartwarming story follows a young girl, Rivka, and her grandmother, Bubbie, as they bake challah together for Shabbat. Their first attempt is not perfect, but instead of giving up, they embrace their mistake and turn it into something new and wonderful. The book beautifully illustrates intergenerational love, resilience, and the joy of shared creation. It’s perfect for families who value process over perfection and want to model a positive approach to trying, failing, and trying again.
The book features Jewish religious and cultural content (Shabbat, challah, Hebrew words like "Bubbie" and "Shabbat Shalom"). The approach is celebratory and accessible, presenting these traditions as a warm, integrated part of family life. It is not overtly theological but is rooted in Jewish cultural practice. No other sensitive topics are present.
A 4 to 6-year-old who is developing an interest in "helping" in the kitchen or with other grown-up tasks. It is also perfect for a child who struggles with perfectionism or gets easily frustrated when things do not go exactly as planned. It provides a gentle model for reframing mistakes as opportunities.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewNo prep needed. The book is straightforward and gentle. Parents might want to be ready to pronounce a few Hebrew words (challah, Bubbie, Shabbat Shalom), which are used naturally in the text. The back matter includes a challah recipe, which parents could preview if they anticipate their child wanting to bake immediately. A parent has just witnessed their child have a small meltdown over a project gone "wrong": a drawing that got smudged, a block tower that fell, or a baking project that got messy. The child is focused on the imperfect outcome and feels like they have failed.
A 4-year-old will focus on the sensory details: the messy dough, the colorful sprinkles, the fun animal shape. They will grasp the simple emotional story of love between a girl and her grandmother. A 7 or 8-year-old can appreciate the more nuanced theme of resilience and creative problem-solving. They might connect the "(So Far!)" in the title to their own experiences of learning a skill over time.
While there are many books about intergenerational cooking, this one's unique strength is its explicit and gentle focus on "happy accidents." It is not just about the tradition, but about the flexibility within tradition. The "so far" framing beautifully captures the idea that skills and relationships are always a work in progress, which is a powerful and reassuring message for young children.
Rivka and her grandmother (Bubbie) bake challah for Shabbat. The process is loving and joyful, but the dough becomes too wet and sticky to braid properly. Instead of seeing it as a failure, they adapt, adding sprinkles and shaping it into a "challah-fant" (an elephant). The story focuses on their loving interaction, creative problem-solving, and the joy of creating something unique together, culminating in sharing their creation at the family Shabbat dinner. The "so far" in the title suggests this is an ongoing tradition of learning.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.