
Reach for this book when your teenager begins to question the social dynamics of your neighborhood or expresses confusion about how past prejudices continue to shape the present. It is a powerful tool for navigating the unsettling moment when a young person realizes that people they love and admire, such as grandparents or community leaders, may hold views or histories that conflict with modern values of equality. The story follows fifteen year old Macey as she investigates a decades old mystery in her affluent town, uncovering a hidden history of racial exclusion. It deals with heavy themes of systemic racism and grief with honesty and integrity. While the subject matter is serious, it serves as an excellent catalyst for discussing civic responsibility and the courage required to confront uncomfortable truths within one's own family and community.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe murder of a peer is the catalyst for the plot.
Themes of grief, disillusionment with family, and social injustice.
The book deals directly with murder and historical racial violence. The approach is realistic and sobering. While Venita's murder happens off-page, the emotional weight is significant. The resolution is realistic rather than neatly tied up: Macey must live with the knowledge of her family's flaws, though there is a hopeful note in her commitment to truth.
A thoughtful 14 to 15 year old who is socially conscious and starting to notice the 'bubbles' they live in. It is perfect for a student who likes mysteries but wants something with real-world stakes.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the concept of 'sundown towns' and the reality of housing discrimination. Preview the scenes where Macey confronts her grandparents to prepare for questions about family loyalty. A parent might see their child becoming cynical about local history or expressing guilt over their own privilege.
Younger teens will focus on the mystery and the unfairness of the crime. Older teens will grasp the nuanced critique of systemic racism and the difficulty of restorative justice.
Unlike many YA books on racism that focus on the victim's perspective, Cooney specifically examines the responsibility and 'un-learning' required of the white community in a wealthy setting.
Macey Clare is a teenager in an affluent, homogenous Connecticut suburb. After a brief encounter with Venita, a Black girl from the inner city who is later murdered, Macey is spurred into a school research project about a 1959 fire in her hometown. Her investigation reveals that the fire was an act of arson intended to drive out a Black family, and she discovers that her own ancestors and neighbors were complicit in the cover-up.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.