
A parent might reach for this book when their teenager is navigating the isolating weight of family trauma, particularly when a sibling is facing a long-term medical crisis. While the story is framed as a high-stakes mystery, it serves as a powerful mirror for the complicated grief, guilt, and resentment that can surface when a family is frozen by tragedy. It is a compelling choice for teens who enjoy propulsive thrillers but also need to process the 'what ifs' that haunt survivors of accidents. Parents should know the book contains suspenseful sequences and themes of betrayal, making it best suited for mature middle schoolers and high school students who can handle an emotionally heavy, realistic portrayal of sibling dynamics and secret-keeping.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewCharacters, including the protagonist, keep significant secrets and lie to those they love.
Moments of psychological tension and the feeling of being watched/followed outdoors.
The book deals directly with medical trauma (comas) and the potential of a peer-inflicted crime. The approach is secular and realistic, focusing on the psychological toll of a loved one's uncertain survival. The resolution provides answers but maintains a somber, realistic tone regarding the family's recovery.
A teenager who feels overshadowed by a sibling or who is struggling with 'survivor guilt' after a family tragedy. It is perfect for the reader who wants the adrenaline of a thriller but with deep, character-driven emotional stakes.
Parents should be aware of the intense atmosphere of suspicion and the depiction of the sister in a vegetative state. No specific scenes require censoring, but the emotional weight of the ending should be discussed. A parent might see their child becoming withdrawn or obsessive following a family member's illness, or expressing anger toward a person they feel was responsible for a 'preventable' accident.
Younger teens (13-14) will likely focus on the 'whodunnit' and the survival aspects of the camping trip. Older teens (16-18) will better grasp the nuance of Savannah's guilt and the complex, often non-linear nature of grief.
Unlike many YA thrillers that focus purely on the crime, this book centers on the specific, painful limbo of having a loved one who is 'gone but still here' (the coma), making the mystery feel deeply personal rather than just a puzzle.
Savannah Sullivan's sister, Piper, is in a coma following a mysterious fall during a hiking trip. When Savannah finds a hidden note in Piper's locker inviting her to a secret meeting at the scene of the accident, she realizes Piper might have been pushed. Savannah joins the school's wilderness club on a camping trip to the same mountain to investigate the members, only to realize that everyone is hiding a motive, and Savannah herself is harboring secrets about her relationship with her 'perfect' sister.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.