
Reach for this book when your child is struggling with a change in routine or feels intense anxiety when their expectations for the day are upended. Whether it is a substitute teacher, a change in schedule, or a different caregiver, this story validates the frustration that comes when the 'right' way of doing things is replaced by someone else's 'new' way. The story follows a young girl who is deeply loyal to her regular teacher, Mrs. P., and finds herself increasingly annoyed by the substitute, Mrs. Fillmore, who does everything differently. Written in the form of a series of letters (some never sent), the book captures the internal monologue of a child who values precision and rules. It is perfect for children ages 4 to 8, especially those who might be described as 'rule-followers' or who struggle with transitions. By the end, the book gently nudges the reader toward the realization that different can sometimes be okay, or even fun, without dismissing the child's initial feelings of resentment. It is a helpful tool for modeling how to navigate 'change of plans' days with resilience.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe book deals with minor emotional distress related to disrupted routines. The approach is direct and secular. The resolution is realistic and hopeful, focusing on the child's internal shift from resistance to acceptance.
A first or second grader who is a rigid rule-follower or a child who experiences high anxiety when their schedule changes. It is particularly suited for children who express their feelings through writing or drawing.
This book can be read cold. Parents might want to highlight the humorous contrast between the child's perception of 'disaster' and the actual harmlessness of the substitute's actions. A parent might see their child coming home from school in a foul mood because 'everything was wrong' or 'it wasn't the way we usually do it,' or perhaps a child refusing to go to school because they know their teacher will be absent.
Younger children (4-5) will focus on the slapstick elements and the physical changes in the room. Older children (7-8) will recognize the sarcasm and the emotional complexity of feeling loyal to one person while starting to like another.
Unlike many 'substitute' books that focus on the substitute being a monster or a hero, this book stays firmly in the child's internal emotional landscape. The epistolary format allows for a unique, first-person exploration of the 'inner critic' of a school-aged child.
The story is told through an epistolary format where a young student writes letters to a substitute teacher, her regular teacher, and even the librarian. The protagonist is disgruntled because the substitute, Mrs. Fillmore, deviates from the established classroom routine: she doesn't use the right folders, she skips the class's favorite subject, and she eats her lunch differently. However, as the day progresses, the student begins to appreciate the unexpected whimsy of the new routine, culminating in a more positive perspective on change.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.