
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is expressing a deep sense of injustice regarding how society treats people who are different, or when they are struggling to find their own voice within rigid systems. It is an essential read for mature teens who are interested in the history of disability rights and the darker chapters of social history. Set in the early 1900s at the Massachusetts School for the Feeble-Minded, the story follows four teenagers: Alice, Maxine, Rose, and London: who have been discarded by society for reasons ranging from physical disability to simply being 'difficult' young women. This novel explores intense themes of bodily autonomy, the cruelty of the eugenics movement, and the profound power of found family. While the setting is historical and often bleak, the emotional core is one of fierce resilience and the refusal to be defined by a label. It is best suited for older teens (14+) due to its honest depiction of institutional abuse and period-typical discrimination. Parents will appreciate how it encourages critical thinking about human rights and the importance of standing up for those the world tries to silence.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewDepicts period-typical ableism and the dehumanizing eugenics movement.
Themes of institutional abuse, forced sterilization, and abandonment.
Characters face physical danger and the threat of permanent medical procedures.
Occasional period-typical harsh language and clinical slurs.
The book deals directly and unflinchingly with institutional abuse, forced sterilization, and the eugenics movement. The approach is secular and historical. The resolution is realistic rather than purely happy, offering a bittersweet sense of survival and agency in a broken system.
A high schooler who feels like an outsider or has a strong interest in social justice. It is particularly resonant for neurodivergent teens or those with physical disabilities who want to understand the history of their community's struggle for rights.
Parents should be aware of scenes depicting medical examinations and the threat of sterilization. It is helpful to provide context regarding the eugenics movement in America to explain that these institutions were real. A parent might notice their child becoming cynical about authority or asking complex questions about why certain people are treated as 'lesser' in history class.
Younger teens (14) will focus on the friendship and the 'escape' element. Older teens (17-18) will likely engage more deeply with the horrifying historical accuracy and the systemic critique of the era.
Unlike many historical novels that focus on the 'great men' of history, this book centers on the voices of those deemed 'degenerate' by society, giving agency back to victims of the eugenics movement.
Set in 1911 at the Massachusetts School for the Feeble-Minded (the Walter E. Fernald State School), the narrative rotates between four protagonists: Maxine, Rose, Alice, and London. Each has been institutionalized for various reasons: pregnancy out of wedlock, physical disability, or 'moral insanity.' Together, they navigate the harrowing reality of the eugenics movement and form a bond to reclaim their dignity.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.