
Reach for this book when your teen is questioning the fairness of modern laws or feeling disillusioned by stories of national history. It is a vital tool for families navigating the nuances of social justice and the gap between a country's ideals and its reality. Through three meticulously researched cases, the book explores how the United States has historically excluded or deported individuals based on ethnicity and political beliefs. It focuses on the human cost of these decisions, highlighting the resilience of young people caught in legal crosshairs. While the themes are somber, it provides a necessary foundation for a more mature, critical understanding of civic responsibility. It is best suited for middle and high school students ready to engage with difficult truths about the dark side of history.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewFocuses on state-sponsored xenophobia, antisemitism, and anti-Asian racism.
Implied and confirmed deaths of historical figures in the Holocaust.
Characters face the constant threat of deportation and government overreach.
The approach is direct and unflinching. It deals with systemic racism, the Holocaust, and government-sanctioned xenophobia. The resolution is realistic: it acknowledges the harm done and the long road to reparations or apologies, rather than offering a tidy, happy ending.
A thoughtful 14-year-old who is active in social justice clubs or a student who has just encountered a simplified version of WWII in class and wants to know the more complex, messy truth.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the MS St. Louis chapter, as the fate of the passengers returned to Europe is tragic. Context regarding the Red Scare and the Holocaust is helpful but the book provides significant historical scaffolding. A parent might see their child reacting with anger to a news story about modern border issues or expressing confusion about why history books sometimes contradict each other.
Younger teens (12-13) will likely connect most with the stories of the children and the sense of unfairness. Older teens (16-18) will better grasp the political machinery and the implications for modern civil liberties.
Bausum excels at narrowing vast historical tragedies down to the perspective of a single individual, making the abstract concept of immigration law deeply personal and visceral for young readers.
The book profiles three historical instances where the United States failed to live up to its inclusive reputation. It covers the 1939 rejection of the MS St. Louis carrying Jewish refugees (focusing on a 12-year-old boy), the forced internment of Japanese Americans during WWII (focusing on a 16-year-old girl), and the deportation of labor activist Emma Goldman.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.