
Reach for this book when your children are trapped in a cycle of constant comparison or when a family loss has left siblings processing their grief in clashing, competitive ways. It is a powerful tool for parents whose children seem to be 'dueling' for attention or status within the home and school environment. The story follows sisters Lucy and Giigi, who are both grieving the death of their father while navigate the social hierarchy of middle school. When they both join the fencing team, their private friction turns into a public rivalry. This graphic novel masterfully explores how anger is often a mask for sadness and how forgiveness is a skill that must be practiced. It is a deeply relatable, emotionally honest choice for children ages 8 to 12 who are navigating the 'messy' side of family love.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe book deals with the death of a parent in a secular, realistic manner. The grief is not the central 'mystery' but rather the atmospheric pressure that influences the sisters' behavior. The resolution is hopeful and grounded in realistic communication rather than a magical fix.
A middle-schooler who feels like they are living in a sibling's shadow, or a child who has lost a parent and finds themselves acting out with anger rather than tears.
Read cold. The graphic novel format makes the emotional beats very accessible, though parents should be ready to discuss the difference between healthy competition and using sports as an outlet for pain. A parent might choose this after witnessing a particularly mean-spirited argument between siblings or seeing a child struggle with the pressure to live up to a sibling's previous successes.
Younger readers (8-9) will focus on the 'fairness' of the sisterly dynamic and the excitement of the fencing matches. Older readers (11-12) will pick up on the nuances of social status, the performative nature of middle school popularity, and the complexity of shared grief.
Unlike many 'sports' books, the athletic focus (fencing) serves as a precise metaphor for the 'thrust and parry' of sibling verbal warfare. It's rare to see a graphic novel balance high-energy sports action with such quiet, devastating emotional honesty about family loss.
Lucy is starting middle school and wants to carve out her own identity, but her popular older sister Giigi seems to overshadow her at every turn. Both girls are competitive fencers, a sport they shared with their late father. As they prepare for a high-stakes tournament, their unresolved grief and mutual resentment boil over into a public feud that threatens their relationship and their standing at school.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.