
Reach for this book when your child is grappling with the consequences of taking a shortcut or is fascinated by the idea that brains can beat brawn (or magic). This Caldecott winning Cornish folk tale centers on Duffy, a girl who is better at avoiding work than doing it. When a mysterious little man offers to do her spinning for her, she accepts the help without considering the cost, eventually leading to a high stakes game of wits to save her future. While the story features a devil, the tone is decidedly humorous and whimsical rather than terrifying. It explores themes of accountability and cleverness, showing that while mistakes can lead to trouble, quick thinking and bravery can resolve even the stickiest situations. It is a fantastic choice for parents who want to introduce folklore that feels earthy, funny, and slightly mischievous, making it perfect for children aged 5 to 9.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewDuffy is dishonest about her skills and 'cheats' to win, which is typical for folk protagonists.
The threat of being taken away creates a sense of urgency and mild tension.
The portrayal of the devil is mythological and secular, functioning as a trickster figure common in European folklore. The threat of being taken away is handled with humor rather than horror. The resolution is triumphant but carries a comical consequence: all the devil's magic clothes disappear.
A child who loves a good trickster story or who finds the 'Rumpelstiltskin' dynamic exciting. It is perfect for a child who enjoys British humor or stories where the protagonist is slightly flawed but likeable.
Read this with your best Cornish or 'old world' accent! The text includes some dialect (like 'flee-doms' for things that fly) that may need a quick explanation, but generally can be read cold. A parent might choose this after seeing their child try to 'wiggle out' of a chore or lie about an accomplishment, using the story to discuss why short-term fixes often have long-term costs.
Younger children (5-6) focus on the funny appearance of the devil and the magic vanishing clothes. Older children (7-9) appreciate the irony of Duffy's situation and the clever way the name is discovered.
The Zemachs' version is unique for its earthy, chaotic illustrations and its refusal to be overly moralistic. It retains the rough edges of authentic folklore while remaining accessible.
Duffy, a young woman in Cornwall, is hired by a Squire who believes she is a master spinner. In reality, she is quite lazy. A small, ugly devil appears and offers to do all her spinning, knitting, and sewing for three years. At the end of that time, he will take her away unless she can guess his name. Duffy enjoys a life of luxury and eventually marries the Squire, but as the deadline approaches, she must rely on her husband's accidental discovery of the devil's name to save herself. When the name is revealed, all the devil's work vanishes, leaving the Squire in just his skin.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.