
Reach for this book when your middle schooler is navigating complex social dynamics, body image concerns, or the heavy burden of keeping a peer's secret. It is an essential choice for parents of children aged 9 to 13 who are beginning to face the reality that friendship sometimes requires difficult, high-stakes decisions regarding a friend's health and safety. While the plot follows Tally on a seventh-grade class trip to Washington, DC, the heart of the story is her growing realization that her roommate and former rival, Ava, is struggling with an eating disorder. The book masterfully explores themes of empathy, loyalty, and the difference between tattling and helping. Barbara Dee provides a realistic, compassionate look at early adolescent struggles without being didactic, making it a safe yet profound entry point for conversations about mental health and body positivity.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe protagonist must decide if breaking a promise to a friend is the right thing to do.
Health-related concerns regarding a character's physical well-being.
The book deals directly and realistically with eating disorders (anorexia/bulimia behaviors). The approach is secular and psychological, focusing on the internal pressure and secrecy involved. The resolution is hopeful but realistic, acknowledging that recovery is a long process rather than a quick fix.
A mature 10 to 12-year-old who is sensitive to the changing behaviors of their peers or a child who struggles with the pressure of perfectionism. It is perfect for the student who is beginning to see behind the 'mask' their classmates wear.
Parents should be aware of the back matter which includes specific resources for eating disorders. It is helpful to read the scenes where Tally discovers Ava's hidden food and exercise logs to prepare for the emotional weight of those moments. A parent might notice their child becoming hyper-aware of their friends' eating habits, or perhaps the child is feeling anxious about a 'secret' a friend has told them that feels too big to keep.
Younger readers (ages 9-10) will focus on the 'detective' aspect and the social drama of the trip. Older readers (12-13) will more deeply internalize the ethical dilemma of breaking a friend's trust to save their life.
Unlike many books on this topic that focus on the sufferer, this book focuses on the bystander. It validates the anxiety and responsibility felt by the friend who notices something is wrong, filling a vital gap in middle-grade literature.
Tally is excited for her 7th grade trip to Washington, DC, despite being paired with her former best friend turned rival, Ava. During the trip, Tally observes Ava's obsessive calorie counting, excessive exercise, and food avoidance. Tally must decide whether to respect Ava's privacy or break a social code to get her help.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.