
A parent might reach for this book when their child is carrying the weight of a secret mistake or when the family is facing a sudden, destabilizing crisis. It is a powerful resource for middle grade readers who struggle with impulse control, specifically regarding 'borrowing' things that do not belong to them, or for children who feel the profound shame of having a parent accused of a crime. Through the eyes of seventh grader Aafiyah, the story explores the complex intersection of personal guilt and external injustice. Written in accessible, poignant verse, the book follows Aafiyah as she navigates her kleptomania while simultaneously trying to clear her father's name after he is falsely accused of theft during a trip to Dubai. It offers a compassionate look at how 'good' kids can make bad choices, emphasizing that one's mistakes do not define their entire worth. It is a deeply empathetic choice for families looking to discuss honesty, the Pakistani-American experience, and the resilience needed to mend family bonds after a period of intense anxiety.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewProtagonist struggles with a stealing habit while her father is accused of theft.
Depicts the legal system in Dubai and the specific anxieties of South Asian immigrant families.
The book deals directly with the incarceration of a parent and the legal system. It is secular but grounded in Muslim cultural traditions. The resolution is hopeful and realistic, focusing on restorative justice and personal accountability rather than a magical 'fix-all' ending.
A 10 to 12 year old child who feels like they have to be 'perfect' for their parents but is secretly struggling with a behavior they find shameful, or a child experiencing the sudden, confusing loss of a parent due to legal issues.
Parents should be prepared for the depiction of Aafiyah's kleptomania, which is portrayed as a compulsive struggle rather than simple malice. Reading the scenes where her father is taken away can be emotionally taxing for sensitive children. A parent might notice their child becoming unusually withdrawn, hiding objects, or reacting with extreme distress to news reports about crime or injustice.
Younger readers (age 8-9) will focus on the mystery of the father's arrest and the tension of the 'borrowing.' Older readers (11-12) will better grasp the nuance of the moral irony Aafiyah faces and the systemic issues of justice.
Unlike many books about 'bad habits,' this one links the child's internal struggle with a massive external family crisis, using the verse format to mirror the fragmented, high-heartbeat feeling of anxiety.
Aafiyah is a Pakistani American middle schooler who loves tennis and 'weird but true' facts. She also struggles with a compulsive habit of stealing small, beautiful items. When her father is detained in Dubai on false charges of stealing a piece of jewelry, Aafiyah’s world shatters. She attempts to use her knowledge and a desperate plan to help her family, all while grappling with the hypocrisy of her own secret habit and the crushing weight of her father's absence.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.