
Reach for this book when your child feels like they have to change their personality to fit in or perform for others. It is a perfect choice for kids who struggle with perfectionism or who worry that being themselves is not enough. The story follows two best friends, Harold and Hog, who try to play pretend by acting like the famous characters Elephant and Piggie. However, they soon realize that their natural personalities do not match the roles they are trying to play. This book explores themes of identity, self-acceptance, and the pressure of expectations. It is ideal for children ages 4 to 8 who are navigating social dynamics and learning to value their unique traits. By using humor and a meta-narrative approach, Dan Santat helps parents open a conversation about why it is okay, and even better, to just be yourself rather than a copy of someone else.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe book deals with identity and the anxiety of performance in a secular, metaphorical way. The resolution is hopeful and validating, emphasizing that authenticity is more important than imitation.
A first grader who loves the Elephant and Piggie series but often feels they don't 'fit the mold' of the popular kids or the characters they admire. It is also excellent for a child who is a literal thinker and struggles with the 'rules' of imaginative play.
This is a 'meta' book. It helps if the child is already familiar with the Elephant and Piggie series, as much of the humor relies on subverting those character tropes. It can be read cold, but the impact is stronger with prior knowledge. A parent might notice their child becoming distressed during a playdate because they are trying too hard to follow someone else's rules or are being told they are 'doing it wrong' by a peer.
Younger children (4-5) will enjoy the slapstick humor and the costumes. Older children (7-8) will grasp the deeper irony of the 'Elephant and Piggie' brand and the social commentary on staying true to one's personality.
It is a unique 'book within a book' that pays homage to a classic series while teaching a distinct lesson about the exhaustion of trying to be someone you are not.
Harold and Hog are best friends who decide to play a game of pretend. They dress up as Mo Willems' iconic characters, Elephant and Piggie. However, Hog (the pig) is naturally serious and careful, unlike the bubbly Piggie, while Harold (the elephant) is cheerful and carefree, unlike the anxious Gerald. They try desperately to fit the scripts and personalities of their idols, but they fail miserably until they realize they can just be their own versions of the characters.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.