
Reach for this book when your child starts asking difficult questions about the fairness of the world, inherited guilt, or why good people sometimes have bad parents. It is a profound choice for pre-teens who are beginning to look beyond their own lives to understand the complexities of history and morality. The story follows a group of modern Australian children waiting for the school bus while one girl, Anna, tells a story about Heidi, the hidden daughter of Adolf Hitler. As the fictional Heidi struggles with her physical disabilities and her father's horrific actions, the modern-day protagonist, Mark, begins to question if we are responsible for the sins of our ancestors. This book is a gentle but serious bridge into historical understanding and moral philosophy, perfect for the child who feels things deeply and seeks to understand the 'why' behind human behavior.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewExplores whether children are responsible for their parents' actions.
Descriptions of bombing raids and the fear of discovery.
Refers to Nazi ideology and the persecution of 'imperfect' people.
The book deals directly with the Holocaust, though the violence is largely off-screen or filtered through Heidi's limited perspective. It addresses physical disability (Heidi's limp and birthmark) and the concept of eugenics. The approach is secular and philosophical. The resolution is realistic and somewhat ambiguous, leaving the heavy lifting of moral judgment to the reader.
A 10 to 12 year old who is a deep thinker and perhaps a bit of an outsider. It is perfect for the child who has just started learning about WWII in school and is struggling to reconcile the existence of such evil with their own sense of safety and family.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the basic facts of the Holocaust and Hitler's rise to power, as the book assumes a baseline of historical knowledge. Page 80-90 (contextualizing the camps) may need a shared reading. A child asking, 'If you did something really bad, would I go to jail too?' or 'Are there just some people who are born evil?'
Younger readers (10) focus on the 'is it true?' mystery of the daughter's existence. Older readers (13-14) engage more with the philosophical burden of heredity and the ethics of silence.
Unlike many Holocaust books that focus on the victims, this focuses on the proximity to the perpetrator, asking if love for a parent can coexist with the knowledge of their crimes.
Set in rural Australia, the narrative structure uses a story-within-a-story. Mark, a thoughtful boy, listens to his friend Anna tell the tale of Heidi, a girl with a limp and a birthmark who is kept hidden by her father, Adolf Hitler. While Heidi lives a life of isolated privilege and 'lessons,' the world around her burns. The book toggles between Heidi's experiences in WWII Germany and Mark's internal moral awakening as he processes the story.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.