A parent might reach for this book when their clever, inquisitive child is ready for a more complex mystery than typical early chapter books offer. This story is perfect for a reader who feels a bit underestimated and enjoys seeing a smart kid outwit the adults. Set in Victorian England, the book follows twelve-year-old Myrtle Hardcastle, a brilliant and determined amateur detective who prefers forensic science to needlepoint. When her neighbor dies under suspicious circumstances, Myrtle launches her own investigation, using her wits and scientific knowledge to uncover the truth. The story champions curiosity, perseverance, and the importance of being true to yourself, even when it goes against expectations. It's a witty, engaging, and empowering read for middle-grade mystery lovers.
The central plot is a murder investigation, so character death is a key topic. The approach is intellectual rather than gruesome, focusing on clues and forensics from Myrtle's scientific perspective. Descriptions of the deceased are clinical, not graphic. The book also deals with the restrictive gender roles of the Victorian era, portraying them as obstacles for Myrtle to overcome. The resolution is hopeful, with justice prevailing through intelligence and determination.
Ideal Reader
A bright, curious 9- to 12-year-old who has graduated from simpler mystery series and is seeking a challenge. This reader enjoys historical settings, wordplay, and stories featuring smart, unconventional protagonists who prove their worth. They likely have an interest in science, puzzles, or seeing kids outsmart adults.
Parent Prep
The book can be read cold. The author does an excellent job of integrating historical context and scientific terminology in an accessible way, often through humorous footnotes from Myrtle's perspective. No pre-reading or external context is necessary for a child to enjoy the story. A parent hears their child say, "That mystery was too easy," or sees them devouring books with clever, independent characters. The child might be showing a strong interest in science, history, or simply loves a good puzzle and is ready for a longer, more intricate plot.
Age Experience
A younger reader (9-10) will be captivated by the fun of the mystery, Myrtle's bold personality, and the adventure. An older reader (11-13) will more fully appreciate the dry wit, the historical details, the social commentary on gender roles, and the clever construction of the mystery's clues and red herrings.
What Makes It Special
This book's unique strength lies in its seamless blend of a classic British mystery with a strong STEM focus. Myrtle's passion for forensic science is not just a character trait, it is the engine of the plot. The distinctive narrative voice, full of witty asides and informative footnotes, sets it apart from other historical mysteries for this age group.
Read plot summary
Twelve-year-old Myrtle Hardcastle, an aspiring detective in Victorian England, is obsessed with the new field of forensic science. When her elderly neighbor, a renowned botanist, dies under suspicious circumstances, Myrtle is convinced it was murder. Despite discouragement from her prosecutor father and the local constable, Myrtle, aided by her unflappable governess, Miss Judson, follows the clues. Her investigation uncovers a trail of rare flowers, a contested will, and a garden full of suspects, proving her investigative instincts are sharp.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.
Discussion Prompts
1
Myrtle often defies the expectations for a 'proper' young lady in her time. What are some of those expectations, and how does Myrtle challenge them? Why is her father so concerned about her behavior?
2
Miss Judson is more than just a governess, she's Myrtle's partner in crime-solving. Describe their relationship. How does Miss Judson support Myrtle in ways other adults do not?
3
Myrtle uses scientific observation and tools like her microscope to solve the case. How does her scientific approach help her see things that the police and other adults miss?
4
Throughout the book, Myrtle's father tries to discourage her investigation. By the end, do you think his opinion of her skills has changed? What specific moments show this change?
