
Reach for this book when your child is experiencing nighttime anxiety or if they have started to imagine scary things hiding under the bed. Instead of dismissing those fears, this story playfully leans into them by suggesting that every child has a personal monster who is actually quite helpful for keeping them in bed. It reframes the scary monster trope into a humorous, essential part of a nightly routine. Ethan's regular monster, Gabe, goes on vacation, leaving Ethan to interview several substitutes. The substitutes just do not measure up: some are too silly, others are too polite, and none have the perfect jagged claws Ethan needs to fall asleep. This book is a wonderful tool for children aged 5 to 8 who appreciate a bit of edge with their humor. It helps normalize the feeling of being afraid while giving kids a sense of agency and humor over the things that go bump in the night.
The book deals with fear of the dark and bedtime anxiety through a metaphorical lens. It is entirely secular and uses humor to strip power away from scary imagery. The resolution is hopeful and circular, affirming that the child is safe in their routine.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewA first or second grader who is starting to develop a sophisticated sense of humor and might be struggling with 'the monsters in the closet.' It is perfect for the child who likes things a little bit spooky but still needs to feel safe.
Read this with plenty of 'monster voices.' The book can be read cold, but it works best if the parent is ready to act out the different personalities of the substitute monsters. A parent might choose this after their child repeatedly calls them back into the room at night, claiming they saw something move in the shadows or under the furniture.
Younger children (5-6) focus on the visual humor of the monsters' physical traits. Older children (7-8) appreciate the irony of a child 'needing' a monster and the 'interview' format of the substitutes.
Unlike most books that try to prove monsters aren't real, this one validates the child's imagination by making the monster a necessary, even beloved, companion. The illustrations are cinematic and use light and shadow beautifully to create a safe sort of spookiness.
When Ethan reaches under the bed for his monster, Gabe, he finds a note instead: Gabe has gone fishing. Ethan realizes he cannot fall asleep without the familiar comfort of Gabe's heavy breathing and ragged claws. A series of substitute monsters appear, but Ethan finds them all lacking. One is too groomed, one is too small, and one is a girl with a bow. Eventually, Gabe returns, and Ethan can finally drift off to sleep, comforted by the presence of his own 'scary' friend.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.