
Reach for this book when your teen feels like an outsider because of the way their mind works, especially if they value logic and observation over social conformity. Abigail Rook is a young woman carving out her own path in 1892 New England who partners with the eccentric R.F. Jackaby, a man who sees supernatural truths hidden behind everyday illusions. Together, they hunt a serial killer that the traditional police refuse to acknowledge exists. While the plot is a fast paced paranormal mystery, the heart of the story lies in the validation of different perspectives. Abigail provides the grounded, practical observation while Jackaby offers the visionary, intuitive leaps. It is an excellent choice for readers who enjoy historical settings but want a modern approach to gender roles and neurodivergent-coded characters. Parents should note there is some macabre imagery related to the murders, making it best suited for mature middle schoolers and up.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewDescriptions of murder victims and a climax involving physical combat.
Characters are frequently in life-threatening situations involving monsters.
Supporting characters and victims are killed during the mystery.
The book deals with murder and death directly. The approach is secular and forensic, though the victims are killed by supernatural means. The resolution is hopeful but realistic about the dangers of their chosen profession.
A 14-year-old who loves logic puzzles, urban fantasy, and characters who don't fit the 'normal' mold. Perfect for the kid who feels they notice the small things everyone else misses.
Preview the descriptions of the crime scenes. While not overly gory by modern YA standards, they are atmospheric and lean into the macabre. A parent might see their child struggling to find a career path or social circle that fits their unconventional interests, or perhaps the child is frustrated by adults who dismiss their observations.
Younger teens will enjoy the 'monster of the week' thrills and the cheeky humor. Older teens will appreciate the subtle commentary on 19th-century gender expectations and the nuanced depiction of Jackaby's unique sensory experience.
The chemistry between the two leads is not a typical romance but a meeting of two different styles of intelligence: Abigail's keen eye for the ordinary and Jackaby's sight for the extraordinary.
In 1892, Abigail Rook arrives in New Fiddleham seeking adventure. She becomes the assistant to R.F. Jackaby, a private investigator of the paranormal. They investigate a series of grisly murders that Jackaby believes are the work of a non-human creature, while the skeptical police hunt a human suspect.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.