
A parent might reach for this book when their child is the new kid in town, feeling lonely and struggling to find their place. It tells the story of Elizabeth, who has just moved to a new apartment, and her first encounter with the strange and self-possessed Jennifer, who claims to be a real witch. To cement their friendship, Elizabeth becomes Jennifer's apprentice. This classic Newbery Honor book gently explores the loneliness of being new, the intricate dance of making a friend, and the incredible power of imagination to build a bridge between two people. It's a quiet, character-driven story perfect for sensitive, thoughtful children.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe core themes are loneliness and social isolation. These are handled directly from the child's perspective but with a gentle, observational tone. The "witchcraft" is entirely a product of the children's imaginations and is not tied to any religious or occult practice; it is a secular framework for their play. The resolution is hopeful and realistic, as the girls find a way to be friends without the pretense.
An introspective, imaginative child aged 8 to 10 who is navigating the challenges of being new, feeling different, or struggling to make a close friend. It is perfect for a reader who appreciates quiet, character-focused stories over fast-paced plots and understands the seriousness of play.
No significant prep is needed; the book can be read cold. Parents may want to note the 1960s setting, which features a level of independence (kids walking to the library and through the woods alone) that is less common today. The witch-related content is very mild and clearly make-believe (a potion might include spit and a dead caterpillar), and should not be a concern for most families. The parent hears their child say, "I don't have any friends," or sees them playing alone at the park or during recess. This book is for the child who is having a hard time breaking into established social groups and might be feeling invisible or left out.
A younger reader (7-8) will likely be captivated by the game itself: is Jennifer a real witch? The rules and rituals will seem fun and mysterious. An older reader (9-10) will grasp the deeper emotional story: that the witch game is a safe structure the girls use to get to know each other. They will appreciate the subtle psychology of their friendship and Elizabeth's journey to finding her own voice.
Unlike many friendship stories that revolve around school drama or group dynamics, this is an intensely focused story about two individuals. Its unique power lies in its deep respect for childhood imagination as a vital tool for connection. It validates the quiet, strange, and serious ways kids can build a world together before they are ready to be vulnerable in the real one.
Elizabeth, new to town and lonely, meets Jennifer, a mysterious and serious girl who announces she is a witch. Elizabeth becomes her apprentice, and their budding friendship is structured around the rules and rituals of their imaginary coven. They meet on specific days, gather ingredients (like toad warts and raw eggs), and work towards a final test. The story follows the development of their secret world, showing how this shared fantasy allows two lonely children to connect and build a genuine friendship that ultimately transcends the need for make-believe.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.