
A parent would reach for this book when their child is facing the temptation to take something that does not belong to them or is struggling with the heavy weight of a secret. It speaks directly to the internal conflict between wanting a short term reward and maintaining one's integrity. The story follows Karen Brewer as she navigates the guilt of a poor choice and the anxiety that comes with trying to hide the truth from those she loves. Written for the 7 to 9 age group, the narrative uses a relatable school and family setting to explore honesty and the restorative power of an apology. Parents will appreciate how it models the process of making amends without being overly preachy. It is an excellent tool for normalizing the fact that everyone makes mistakes, but what matters most is how we fix them. The book provides a safe space to discuss peer pressure and the physical feeling of a guilty conscience.



















Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe book deals with minor theft and lying. The approach is direct and secular, focusing on the social and emotional consequences of the actions rather than legal or religious ones. The resolution is hopeful and realistic, emphasizing that relationships can be repaired through honesty.
An 8-year-old who is starting to navigate more complex social environments at school where the 'rules' aren't always being watched by an adult, and who needs to understand the value of a clear conscience.
This book can be read cold. It serves as a great conversation starter about the 'butterfly' feeling in your stomach when you know you've done something wrong. A parent might choose this after finding a 'stashed' item in their child's room or noticing their child acting unusually secretive or defensive when asked about their day.
Younger readers (age 7) will focus on the 'right vs. wrong' of taking the candy. Older readers (age 9) will more keenly feel Karen's social anxiety and the fear of losing her friends' trust.
Part of the beloved Baby-Sitters Little Sister series, this book uses a familiar, low-stakes environment to tackle the very high-stakes emotion of shame, making it accessible rather than intimidating.
Karen Brewer finds herself in a moral dilemma involving candy and a choice that tests her honesty. After making a mistake and taking something that isn't hers, she experiences the mounting pressure of guilt. The story focuses on her internal struggle, her fear of being caught, and her eventual decision to come clean and apologize to her friends and family.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.