
Reach for this book when your daughter begins asking the big, awkward questions about her changing body or expresses confusion about where she fits in socially and spiritually. It is a quintessential guide for the pre-teen years, capturing the internal monologue of a girl who feels like she is the last one to reach every milestone. The story follows Margaret Simon as she moves to a new town, navigates the unspoken rules of a new friend group, and initiates a private, sincere dialogue with God about her anxieties. It normalizes everything from buying a first bra to the anticipation of a first period. Parents will appreciate the book for its honesty and the way it validates the intensity of middle-school emotions. It serves as a gentle bridge for conversations about faith, family dynamics, and physical development, offering a reassuring voice that tells every young reader they are perfectly normal just as they are.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewMentions of 1970s menstrual products (sanitary belts) may require explanation.
Characters engage in peer pressure and minor gossip/bullying of a classmate.
The book deals directly with puberty, menstruation, and religious conflict. The approach is secular and highly realistic. The resolution of the religious arc is somewhat ambiguous: Margaret does not choose a specific faith, but she finds peace in her personal connection to the divine. The physical development arc is hopeful and grounded.
A 10 to 12 year old girl who feels behind her peers physically or socially, or a child from an interfaith household who feels caught between different family expectations.
Parents should be prepared for the frank mention of sanitary belts (an outdated technology) and the specific scene where the girls look at a boy's anatomy book. The religious conflict between grandparents is also quite sharp and may need context regarding family boundaries. A parent might see their child performing 'exercises' to speed up physical growth or notice their child becoming increasingly secretive about their friendship group's 'rules.'
Younger readers (9-10) focus on the 'secret club' and the mystery of growing up. Older readers (12-13) connect more with the social anxiety and the search for an individual identity apart from parents.
Unlike modern guides to puberty, this is a narrative that prioritizes the internal emotional experience over clinical facts. It remains the gold standard for its honest depiction of a child's private relationship with God outside of organized religion.
Margaret Simon moves from NYC to the suburbs of New Jersey just as she enters sixth grade. She joins a secret club with three other girls where they discuss boys, bras, and the onset of puberty. Simultaneously, Margaret navigates an independent search for a religious identity, caught between her mother's Christian background and her father's Jewish heritage, while maintaining a personal, colloquial prayer life with God.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.