
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is feeling the intense social pressure of high school hierarchies or struggling with the realization that their first crush is unavailable. It is particularly valuable for supporting a child who feels like an outsider due to their weight, religion, or sexual orientation. The story follows Justin Goldblatt, a self-described chubby, Jewish, and gay sophomore who creates a high-stakes plan to become popular by dating the star quarterback. As the plan hilariously and painfully unravels, the book explores themes of self-confidence, the negative effects of bullying, and the importance of genuine friendship over social status. While the tone is witty and humorous, it handles the complexities of a gay teenager's experience with genuine care. Parents will appreciate the honest look at the 'popularity' trap and the healthy realization that being oneself is more rewarding than fitting in. It is an ideal choice for 13 to 17-year-olds navigating the awkward transition into older adolescence.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewRealistic high school dialogue including some mild profanity.
Explores the loneliness of being bullied and social isolation.
The book deals directly and secularly with sexual identity, body image, and bullying. The bullying is realistic and sometimes sharp, but the resolution is hopeful and focuses on self-acceptance and repairing authentic relationships.
A 14-year-old who feels like they are on the periphery of their school's social scene and thinks that 'if only' they were cooler, their problems would disappear. It's for the kid who uses humor as a defense mechanism.
Parents should be aware of the frank discussions regarding teen crushes and high school social politics. Reading the scenes where Justin ignores Spencer for the sake of popularity can be a good starting point for talking about loyalty. A parent might see their child desperately trying to change their appearance or interests to fit in with a specific group, or notice their child distancing themselves from a long-term 'unpopular' best friend.
Younger teens (13-14) will likely focus on the humor and the 'mission' of the popularity plan. Older teens (16-17) will better appreciate the satirical take on social hierarchies and the nuances of the identity struggle.
Unlike many 'coming out' stories that focus on trauma, this book uses Seth Rudetsky's signature wit to frame the gay experience through the lens of a classic, high-stakes high school social comedy.
Justin Goldblatt enters his sophomore year with a 'Popularity Plan' designed to catapult him to the top of the social ladder. His targets are specific: date the star quarterback (who is straight) and join the 'in' crowd. The plan backfires when he attracts the attention of the quarterback's girlfriend instead of the athlete himself, causing a rift with his best friend Spencer. Through a series of comedic and cringeworthy events, Justin learns that his quest for status is hurting the people who actually care about him.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.