My State

Name: My State
ISBN: 9781644934166

by Meg Gaertner

For mature readers drawn to the Jazz Age's shadowy allure, this story exposes the gripping fight for fame and freedom amidst scandal and corruption.

Find on Bookshop.org Find on Amazon Save

About This Book

A parent might reach for this book when their older teen is fascinated by true crime, celebrity culture, and the complex moral questions of fame and justice. Based on the story of the musical Chicago, it follows two murderesses in the 1920s who manipulate the media and the legal system to become famous, believing celebrity will save them from execution. It's a sharp, satirical look at corruption and celebrity worship that directly explores themes of jealousy, ambition, and moral ambiguity. Best for mature teens (16+), this story is an excellent catalyst for conversations about ethics, media manipulation, and historical social issues in a compelling, darkly humorous package.

History Jealousy & Comparison Mystery Justice & Fairness Music Self-Confidence & Identity Humor Fear & Bravery

What Parents Should Know

Moral AmbiguityIntense

Protagonists are murderers who are celebrated; the entire justice system is portrayed as corrupt.

ViolenceModerate

Murders are central to the plot but are often stylized and not graphically detailed.

Romantic ContentModerate

Story includes infidelity, seduction as a tool for manipulation, and suggestive themes.

Substance ReferencesModerate

Set during Prohibition, so illicit alcohol use and smoking are frequent and part of the atmosphere.

Sensitive Topics

The story's approach to murder is direct but highly stylized and darkly comedic, used as a catalyst for ambition rather than a source of grief. The legal system is portrayed directly and cynically as a corrupt performance where truth is irrelevant. The resolution is realistic within its satirical world: the guilty can be acquitted through fame and manipulation. Infidelity and seduction are key plot points.

Ideal Reader

A 16 to 18 year old who enjoys historical fiction, true crime, and social satire. They appreciate dark humor and morally ambiguous characters and are ready to discuss media ethics, the justice system, and the concept of celebrity.

Parent Prep

Parents should be prepared for the story's complete moral ambiguity. The protagonists are murderers, and their cunning is celebrated over integrity. The book requires contextual discussion about why the characters' actions are problematic, even when presented as entertainment. It can be read cold, but the conversation is essential. A parent hears their teen expressing a cynical view of the justice system or a fascination with "famous for being famous" celebrity culture. The parent is looking for a way to channel that interest into a discussion about media literacy and ethics.

Discussion Prompts

Roxie and Velma compete for the public's affection to win their freedom. What does the story say about the relationship between fame and justice? Can someone be 'famous enough' to be innocent?

Lawyer Billy Flynn claims that the courtroom is 'all a circus.' Do you agree with his view of the legal system as pure performance? Find examples where telling a good story was more important than the truth.

Compare Roxie's and Velma's methods for gaining fame. Which character do you think is more cunning, and why? Do you believe either character feels real guilt for their crimes?

The story is set in the 1920s, but its themes of celebrity scandal feel very modern. What parallels can you draw between Roxie's story and today's 24/7 news cycle and social media culture?