
Reach for this book when your child feels that their truth is being dismissed by adults or when they are struggling to navigate the social fallout of being 'different' among their peers. It is a deeply empathetic look at the bond between brothers and the weight of holding a secret that sounds like a lie. After Aidan disappears for six days and returns with a story about a magical portal in the attic, his younger brother Lucas is the only one who truly listens, even as their parents, the police, and the town demand a more logical explanation. This story is less about the mechanics of fantasy and more about the emotional reality of trust, loyalty, and the loneliness of not being believed. It is perfectly suited for middle grade readers who are beginning to understand that the world is not always black and white and that sometimes, protecting the people we love means accepting their truth without proof.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThemes of isolation, grief over a missing sibling, and the pain of being misunderstood.
The central conflict is whether truth is defined by facts or by personal experience.
The book deals with the trauma of a missing child and the suspicion of foul play. The approach is realistic and secular, focusing on the psychological toll on the family. The resolution is famously ambiguous: Levithan never confirms if the fantasy world was real or a coping mechanism, leaving the reader to decide what 'truth' means.
A thoughtful 10 to 12 year old who values nuance. It is perfect for the child who feels like an outsider or who has been accused of lying when they were telling their own version of the truth. It also serves children dealing with the changing dynamics of sibling relationships as they grow up.
Read cold, but be prepared for the ending. Parents who prefer neat resolutions should be ready to discuss why the author leaves the mystery unsolved. A parent might see their child being isolated at school or feel a disconnect when their child stops sharing their inner life because they fear judgment or disbelief.
Younger readers (age 8-9) often focus on the mystery of the portal and may feel frustrated by the lack of a definitive 'yes.' Older readers (11-12) will better grasp the social commentary on how communities turn on families during scandals.
Unlike most portal fantasies, this book takes place entirely AFTER the character returns, focusing on the grueling reality of being a 'hero' in a world that only sees a troubled kid.
Lucas's older brother Aidan goes missing for six days, sparking a massive police search and town-wide panic. When Aidan is found in the attic, he claims he traveled to a Narnia-like world through a dresser. As the police investigate potential kidnapping and his parents seek psychological help, Lucas becomes the sole guardian of Aidan's story, navigating the social stigma and the internal struggle of wanting to believe his brother while facing a world that demands 'the real story.'
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.