
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is navigating the painful disconnect between a summer romance and the harsh reality of school social hierarchies. It is a vital resource for teens who feel like they are being hidden by a friend or partner, or for those struggling with the pressure to fit into a specific mold. The story follows Ollie, who moves across the country only to find his summer fling, Will, is a different person at school: closeted, acting like a 'jock,' and occasionally a jerk. Beyond the romance, the book handles a heavy family situation involving a terminal illness with grace and realism. It explores themes of authenticity, the courage required to be out in high school, and the importance of surrounding yourself with friends who value the real you. While it features typical high school party scenes and language, it serves as an excellent mirror for queer youth and a window for others into the complexities of identity and peer pressure. It is a hopeful, funny, yet grounded choice for ages 14 and up.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewIncludes kissing, heavy pining, and discussions of sexual identity and attraction.
Contains standard high school profanity (f-words, etc.) consistent with YA contemporary fiction.
Depictions of high school parties where underage drinking occurs.
Explores the pain of being 'closeted' and the emotional toll of family illness.
The book deals directly and secularly with terminal cancer (Ollie's aunt). The approach is realistic and heartbreaking, showing the toll on the family. LGBTQ+ identity and the 'closet' are handled with nuance: Will's fear is validated but his poor treatment of Ollie is not excused. The resolution is hopeful but acknowledges that growth is a process.
A high schooler who loves 'Grease' but wants a modern, queer perspective. Specifically, a teen who feels 'second best' in a relationship or is struggling with a friend who acts differently in different crowds.
Parents should be aware of typical YA content: drinking at parties, some sexual references (not explicit), and heavy themes of death/grief regarding the aunt. A parent might hear their child say, 'My friend is totally different when his other friends are around,' or notice their child is being kept a secret by someone they like.
Younger teens (13-14) will focus on the 'will-they-won't-they' romance. Older teens will better appreciate the internal conflict Will faces regarding his private vs. public identity and the complexity of the family grief.
It perfectly balances a 'fluffy' rom-com aesthetic with genuine, messy emotional stakes, particularly regarding the intersection of romance and family tragedy.
After a magical summer romance, Ollie moves to North Carolina only to realize he is attending the same school as his summer fling, Will. However, the sweet guy Ollie knew is now a closeted class clown who ignores him to maintain his 'bro' reputation. Ollie must navigate a new social circle, his aunt's battle with cancer, and the decision of whether to give Will a second chance.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.