
Reach for this book when you notice the distance between your children widening, particularly if one sibling feels overshadowed by the other's charm or social success. Ordinary Girls is a witty and relatable modern retelling of Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility, centered on sisters Plum and Ginny. As their family faces financial uncertainty in the suburbs of Harrisburg, the girls must navigate their own clashing personalities and public reputations. It masterfully addresses themes of sibling jealousy, the pressure to be 'extraordinary,' and the realization that the people we live with are often the ones we understand least. For parents of teens, it provides a grounded look at sisterhood that is both sharply funny and deeply empathetic, making it an excellent bridge for discussing family loyalty and individual identity.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewOccasional use of mild profanity consistent with contemporary teen fiction.
Themes of financial instability and fear of losing one's home.
The book deals with financial hardship and the threat of job loss in a very grounded, secular, and realistic way. It also touches on social reputation and the impact of public perception. The resolution is hopeful but realistic, focusing on internal growth rather than a magical solution to the family's problems.
A teenager who feels like the 'responsible' or 'invisible' sibling. It's perfect for a reader who enjoys witty, character-driven stories like those by Rainbow Rowell or Jenny Han, but wants something centered on the sister relationship.
The book can be read cold. It features standard YA themes of dating and social drinking (mild), but nothing that requires prior vetting for the 12-17 age range. A parent might see their children constantly bickering or pigeonholing each other into 'the smart one' or 'the difficult one' and want a narrative that disrupts those tropes.
Younger readers (12-13) will likely identify with the frustration of feeling compared to a sibling. Older teens (16-17) will better appreciate the Austen-esque social commentary and the nuances of the family's financial stress.
Unlike many YA romances, this is a true 'sister' story where the primary growth happens between the siblings, using the Austen framework to critique modern social expectations.
Plum and Ginny are sisters living in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, who couldn't be more different. Plum is academic, cautious, and considers herself the 'ordinary' one, while Ginny is vibrant, impulsive, and socially magnetic. When their family's financial stability takes a hit and their mother's job is at risk, the sisters' internal friction is amplified by external pressures. The story follows their navigation of high school social hierarchies, first romances, and the struggle to maintain their family bond as their world feels like it's shrinking.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.