
A parent would reach for this book when their child is curious about complex family dynamics, particularly if there is a 'hush' around certain relatives or historical family trauma. Set in 1953, the story follows eleven-year-old Penny as she navigates life between her mother's side of the family and her father's large, boisterous Italian-American clan. It is a masterful exploration of how secrets and grief can divide families, and how the search for truth can lead to healing. The book deals with themes of loss, cultural identity, and the lingering effects of World War II on immigrant families. It is perfectly appropriate for middle-grade readers, offering a relatable lens through which to view heavy topics like the polio epidemic and historical discrimination against Italian-Americans. Parents will appreciate how Jennifer Holm balances the weight of these themes with the warmth of Sunday dinners, baseball, and the simple joys of a 1950s summer.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewDiscusses historical prejudice against Italian-Americans during WWII.
Penny is injured in an accident, leading to a hospital stay.
The book deals with the death of a parent and the historical reality of Italian-Americans being labeled 'enemy aliens' during WWII. The approach is direct but filtered through a child's understanding. It is secular in nature, and the resolution is realistic and hopeful, providing closure without erasing the past.
A 10-year-old who enjoys historical fiction and is starting to notice that the adults in their life have 'hidden' histories or complicated relationships they don't fully explain.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the historical context of WWII internment and the 'enemy alien' designation, as this is the central mystery's core. No specific scenes require censoring, but the polio hospital scene is poignant. A parent might see their child noticing a discrepancy in family stories or asking why certain relatives don't get along, leading to this recommendation.
Younger readers (8-9) will focus on the baseball and the fun of the Italian family dinners. Older readers (11-12) will better grasp the historical injustice and the weight of the family's shared silence.
Unlike many historical novels that focus solely on the war, this highlights the domestic aftermath of being 'the enemy' at home, told with a unique blend of humor and deep pathos.
Penny is an 11-year-old girl living in 1953, caught between her mother's small, reserved family and her late father's large, loud Italian-American family. As she navigates a summer filled with baseball, polio fears, and a favorite uncle living in a car, she begins to realize that neither side is telling her the full story about how her father died. Her journey is one of piecing together her identity through food, tradition, and the eventual revelation of a painful family secret.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.