
A parent might reach for this book when their middle schooler is struggling with feelings of being an outsider or is fixated on becoming popular. The story follows eighth-grader Patty Dillman, who makes a New Year's resolution to befriend the wealthy and popular Penni Pendleton. This seemingly simple goal sends Patty on an emotional journey of self-discovery, forcing her to confront jealousy, insecurity, and the true meaning of friendship. This gentle, character-driven novel is perfect for ages 11-14, normalizing the common anxieties of navigating middle school social hierarchies. It’s a wonderful choice for opening conversations about self-worth, authenticity, and what makes a real, lasting friendship.
The book's primary sensitive topic is socioeconomic disparity. This is handled directly and realistically through Patty's internal monologue and her observations of Penni's life versus her own. The approach is secular. The resolution is both hopeful and realistic, as Patty doesn't magically become popular but instead achieves a more valuable form of self-acceptance and appreciation for her authentic relationships.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe ideal reader is an 11- to 13-year-old who feels on the outside looking in. This book is for the child who is quiet, observant, and may be feeling lost in the complex social world of middle school, comparing themselves to peers and wondering where they fit in.
No special preparation is needed; the book can be read cold. The themes of class-consciousness and jealousy are presented in a very accessible and gentle way, but a parent can be ready to discuss these ideas if the child brings them up. A parent has heard their child say, "I wish I was popular," or "Everyone has cooler clothes/a bigger house than me." The child may seem withdrawn or express deep frustration about their friend group and social status at school.
A younger reader (11-12) will likely connect most with the plot of trying to make a new friend and the relatable feelings of social awkwardness. An older reader (13-14) will better appreciate the subtler themes of authenticity, the critique of materialism, and Patty's significant internal growth.
Unlike many contemporary books that feature high-stakes drama, this book's power lies in its quiet, realistic portrayal of a common internal struggle. It’s a timeless character study that focuses on the nuances of everyday emotions. Its gentle, introspective tone makes it a comforting classic for navigating the anxieties of belonging.
Eighth-grader Patty Dillman feels ordinary and invisible. For her New Year's resolution, she decides to do whatever it takes to become friends with Penni Pendleton, the prettiest, richest, and most popular girl in her grade. Patty's quest involves trying to change her appearance, navigating awkward social encounters, and comparing her own middle-class family life to Penni's glamorous one. Along the way, she grapples with her loyalty to her long-time best friend, Tracy, and ultimately learns that popularity and wealth don't equate to happiness or true friendship.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.