
A parent might reach for this book when their child is frustrated with a friend's annoying habits, struggling to understand that no one is perfect. It's a fantastic tool for navigating the normal ups and downs of childhood friendships. In this classic story, two best friends, Rosie and Michael, take turns explaining why they are friends. They don't just list the good things, they also cheerfully point out each other's flaws: Michael is cheap, Rosie is a sore loser, and they both show off. This honest and humorous approach teaches children about loyalty, acceptance, and the nature of true connection. For ages 4 to 8, it models a secure friendship that can withstand imperfections, opening a conversation about loving friends for exactly who they are, warts and all.
There are no significant sensitive topics like death or divorce. The book deals with negative character traits (e.g., showing off, being bossy, being cheap) in a direct, humorous, and secular way. The resolution is entirely hopeful, framing these flaws not as dealbreakers, but as manageable parts of a whole person within a secure friendship.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThis book is perfect for a 5 to 8 year old who is beginning to notice their friends' flaws and feels frustrated by them. It's for the child who comes home upset because a friend was too bossy or wouldn't share properly. It's also validating for a child who worries that their own imperfections make them a bad friend.
No parent prep is needed. The book can be read cold. The straightforward text and classic illustrations are easy to understand. A parent might consider thinking about an example from their own friendships to share, modeling that this is a lifelong aspect of relationships. The parent hears their child say, "I don't want to be friends with Sam anymore. He always brags!" or "She's a bad friend because she cried when she lost the game." The trigger is the child's struggle with black and white thinking about friendship and their inability to hold both positive and negative feelings for a friend at the same time.
A younger child (4-5) will enjoy the rhythmic back and forth and the funny, relatable examples of behavior. The core message they'll get is simple: friends aren't perfect. An older child (6-8) will grasp the more nuanced idea of unconditional acceptance. They can analyze the specific traits mentioned and reflect more deeply on the give and take required in their own friendships.
Unlike many books that focus on a single conflict and its resolution, this book's uniqueness lies in its celebration of friendship *in spite of* ongoing, unresolved, and annoying character traits. It normalizes the chronic, low-level friction that exists in all relationships, teaching a sophisticated form of loyalty and acceptance in a very simple package. The direct cataloging of flaws is refreshingly honest and humorous.
The book alternates perspectives between two best friends, Rosie and Michael. Each one describes things they like about the other (e.g., sharing gum, being brave) and things that are annoying (e.g., being a sore loser, being cheap). Despite this long list of flaws and foibles, they conclude that they are still best friends because the good outweighs the bad and they fundamentally like each other.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.