
A parent would reach for this book when their teenager is grappling with a life-altering setback, particularly the loss of a dream or a physical injury that changes their identity. It is an essential read for kids who have tied their entire self-worth to a single talent or sport and suddenly find themselves at a crossroads. Through the eyes of a loyal best friend, the story explores the complex process of grieving a former self and finding the courage to build a new future. Set in the high-stakes world of high school baseball, the book follows Todd, a star pitcher whose career is ended by a traumatic injury, and Paulie, who must navigate how to support a friend in crisis. It tackles heavy themes of resilience, the shifting dynamics of friendship, and the difficult transition into adulthood with realism and heart. It is best suited for readers aged 12 and up due to the emotional intensity of the injury and the mature process of redefining ones life purpose.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewA graphic on-field sports injury involving a head strike and eye loss.
Occasional realistic high school locker room dialogue.
The book deals directly with physical disability and traumatic injury. The approach is secular and starkly realistic. There are no miracle cures; Todd must learn to live with a prosthetic eye and the permanent loss of his athletic dominance. The resolution is hopeful but grounded in reality, as Todd eventually chooses a career in business.
A middle or high school athlete who is currently sidelined by injury, or a teenager who feels like their 'one thing' has been taken away. It is also perfect for the 'loyal sidekick' friend who struggles with how to help someone in deep grief.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the finality of the injury. There is no 'Disney ending' where he returns to the mound and wins the championship. The book requires context about how life goals can evolve. The scene of the injury itself is visceral and may be difficult for parents of athletes. The subsequent depiction of Todd's withdrawal and loss of spark is a poignant representation of adolescent depression.
Younger readers will focus on the sports action and the 'scary' aspect of the injury. Older readers will resonate with the existential dread of 'what comes next' and the changing nature of childhood friendships as graduation approaches.
Unlike many sports books that focus on the comeback to the field, this book is unique because it focuses on the life after the comeback fails. It honors the grief of lost potential rather than offering a cliché of overcoming the odds through sports.
Todd Bannister is a local legend, a high school pitcher destined for the Major Leagues. His best friend, Paulie Lockwood, is his biggest supporter and unofficial manager. During a game, a line drive hits Todd in the head, causing him to lose an eye and his chance at a professional career. The story focuses on the aftermath: Todd's struggle with his new physical reality and the emotional toll of losing his identity, while Paulie learns that he cannot 'fix' his friend's life, but can only walk alongside him as they both pivot toward a new, albeit different, future.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.