
Reach for this book when your teenager is feeling disconnected from their family history or is starting to ask deeper questions about who their ancestors were beyond the stories told at holiday dinners. This story follows Abby Schoenberg as she travels to Nantucket to uncover the truth behind a stack of mysterious letters found in her grandmother's belongings. It is a sophisticated coming of age story that balances the excitement of a summer romance with the weight of uncovering long-buried secrets from the Holocaust era. Parents will appreciate how the book handles complex emotional themes like Jewish identity, the lasting impact of historical trauma, and the ethics of digging into the private lives of those we love. While it features a sweet and engaging romance, the heart of the book lies in Abby's quest for truth and her developing self-confidence. It is an excellent choice for 14 to 18 year olds who enjoy historical mysteries and are ready for a story that treats their intellectual and emotional curiosity with respect.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewExploration of the Holocaust and the loss of family members.
Occasional use of mild profanity.
Instances of underage drinking at summer parties.
Discussions of antisemitism both historical and contemporary.
The book deals directly with the Holocaust and antisemitism, though through a historical lens of discovery rather than lived scenes of the war. The approach is secular but deeply rooted in Jewish cultural identity. The resolution is realistic and bittersweet, providing closure without erasing the gravity of historical loss.
A high schooler who loves a good 'academic' mystery or a 'summer at the beach' vibe, but who also wants a story with real meat on its bones. Perfect for a teen exploring their own heritage or someone who enjoys the 'enemies to lovers' trope with a side of genealogy.
Parents should be aware that there is some mild underage drinking and scenes of physical intimacy (non-explicit). It is helpful to be ready to discuss how historical events like WWII shaped personal family trees. A parent might notice their teen becoming more inquisitive about family heirlooms or expressing frustration with 'sanitized' versions of family history. The trigger is often a child's realization that their parents or grandparents had full, complex lives before they were born.
Younger teens (13-14) will likely focus on the 'detective' aspect and the romantic tension. Older teens (16-18) will better grasp the nuance of the grandmother's choices and the weight of inherited trauma.
Unlike many YA romances, this book uses the 'summer love' framework to host a genuinely compelling historical investigation, making the past feel as urgent and vibrant as the present.
After her grandmother passes away, Abby Schoenberg discovers a cache of letters from a man named Edward. To learn more about her grandmother's life before she escaped Germany during WWII, Abby travels to Nantucket. There, she meets Edward's grandson, Noah. Together, they navigate a budding romance while pieceing together a story of love, sacrifice, and the difficult choices made during the Holocaust.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.