
Reach for this book when your child feels like an outsider within their own home or is beginning to challenge the 'us versus them' mentalities of their community. Set in rural Arkansas during World War II, it follows 12-year-old Patty Bergen, a Jewish girl who feels unloved by her abusive father and cold mother. When she strikes up a secret, profound friendship with an escaped German prisoner of war named Anton, she discovers a sense of worth that her family has denied her. This story is a powerful exploration of empathy, the complexity of moral choices, and the pain of standing up for what is right when everyone else says you are wrong. It is best suited for mature middle schoolers, as it deals directly with themes of emotional and physical abuse, prejudice, and the heavy consequences of personal integrity.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewA primary character is shot and killed by authorities while trying to escape.
Depicts antisemitism, anti-German sentiment, and systemic racism in the Jim Crow South.
Themes of profound loneliness, parental rejection, and legal punishment of a child.
Includes some period-typical insults and derogatory terms.
The book deals very directly with child abuse. Patty's father is physically and emotionally abusive, and her mother is neglectful. The prejudice against Jews in the South and the hatred toward Germans are central. The ending is realistic and somewhat bleak, as Patty loses her freedom and her friend, though she gains a new sense of self-respect. It is a secular historical narrative.
A thoughtful 12 to 14-year-old who is experiencing a rift with their parents or peers due to their evolving personal values. It is for the child who feels like a 'black sheep' and needs to see a protagonist who survives social ostracization.
Parents should definitely preview the scenes of physical abuse by Patty's father (Chapter 7 and 13) which are visceral. The use of period-typical derogatory language and the harshness of the ending also require some contextual discussion about the legalities of the time. A parent might see their child withdrawing from family activities or expressing deep frustration with 'unfair' social rules or local prejudices. The child might feel they are being treated as a 'problem' for simply having a different perspective.
Younger readers (11) might focus on the adventure of the 'secret friend' and the injustice of the town's reaction. Older readers (14-15) will more deeply feel the psychological weight of the family dysfunction and the moral ambiguity of Patty's 'treason.'
Unlike many WWII books that focus on the European theater, this provides a rare look at the American home front, specifically the intersection of Southern Jewish identity and the presence of German POWs in the United States.
Patty Bergen is a lonely Jewish girl living in a small Arkansas town during WWII. Her life changes when a group of German POWs arrives. She befriends Anton, a prisoner who escapes, and hides him in her family's rooms above the garage. Through their conversations, Patty realizes Anton is a kind, educated man rather than the monster her town portrays. After Anton is killed while fleeing and Patty's role is discovered, she faces the wrath of her community and the legal system, eventually being sent to a reformatory school.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.