
Reach for this book when your middle schooler is feeling 'out of sorts' with their changing body, their family dynamics, or their own sense of self worth. It is a perfect choice for siblings of neurodivergent children who may feel a complicated mix of fierce protection and occasional resentment. The story follows fourteen year old Sara, whose summer of teenage angst is interrupted when her younger brother Charlie, who has a cognitive disability, goes missing. As the search for Charlie intensifies, Sara's perspective shifts from internal self criticism to external empathy. This Newbery Medal winner is a gentle, realistic exploration of growing up and finding your place within a family. It is best suited for ages 10 to 14, providing a safe space to discuss the complexities of loving someone who is different and the awkward transition into adolescence.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThemes of self loathing and the social isolation of a child with a disability.
The book deals directly with cognitive disability (Charlie's condition is attributed to 'brain fever' as an infant). The approach is realistic and secular, focusing on the social and emotional impact on the family. The resolution is hopeful but grounded in reality, acknowledging that while Charlie is found, the daily challenges of his disability remain.
A 12 year old girl who feels like an outsider in her own skin, or a child who has a sibling with special needs and needs to see their own complex feelings reflected back at them.
Parents should be aware of the 1970s setting, which may require explaining why there are no cell phones during a search. The term 'mentally retarded' was common at the time of publication and appears in some editions; parents may want to discuss evolving language regarding disability. A parent might choose this after hearing their child say 'I hate my life' or witnessing their child express embarrassment or frustration toward a sibling with a disability.
Younger readers (10) will focus on the mystery of the missing brother and the scary prospect of being lost. Older readers (13 to 14) will connect more deeply with Sara's internal monologue about identity and her changing feelings toward boys.
Unlike many 'disability books' that focus solely on the person with the disability, this book expertly centers the sibling's experience, validating the messy, non-perfect emotions that come with that role.
Sara Godfrey is having a miserable summer, feeling 'huge' and 'ugly' while dealing with the typical frustrations of being fourteen. Her world revolves around her own insecurities until her younger brother Charlie, who became mentally disabled after a childhood illness, wanders off in the middle of the night to find the swans he saw at the lake. The narrative follows Sara's desperate search for Charlie, aided by a boy she previously disliked, Joe Melby.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.