
A parent might reach for this book when their teenager is struggling with the pervasive feeling of being an outsider or when they seem overwhelmed by the mundane pressures of high school. While the setting is a school for witches and mutants, the narrative focuses entirely on the relatable, often awkward emotional reality of adolescence. It is a perfect choice for a child who feels that their inner life is too weird or too intense for the world around them. The book follows a diverse cast of students who grapple with unrequited crushes, body image, and the search for identity. Jillian Tamaki uses humor and surrealism to validate the teenage experience, showing that even if you can fly or cast spells, you still have to deal with social anxiety and existential dread. Because it deals with themes of sexuality and mild existential angst, it is best suited for readers aged 14 and up who appreciate a dry, indie-comic sensibility.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewOccasional use of profanity appropriate for a high school setting.
Absurdist humor sometimes treats dark or strange situations with nonchalance.
Deals with loneliness, social isolation, and the fear of growing up.
The book deals with sexual identity (specifically Marsha's closeted feelings) in a realistic, secular manner. It also touches on existentialism and depression through the character of the Everlasting Boy, whose attempts at self-harm are depicted metaphorically and through the lens of absurdist immortality. The resolution is realistic and reflective rather than purely happy.
A creative, slightly cynical 15-year-old who feels out of sync with their peers and finds comfort in dry humor and alternative art styles.
Parents should be aware of some mild sexual references, brief artistic nudity (non-sexual), and themes of existential despair. It is best to read cold to allow the teen to discover its offbeat rhythm. A parent might see their teen becoming increasingly withdrawn, obsessed with niche subcultures, or expressing frustration that 'nothing matters' or that they don't fit in anywhere.
Younger teens (14) will enjoy the 'mutant' school tropes and the humor. Older teens (17-18) will resonate more deeply with the graduation anxiety and the complex social dynamics.
Unlike most 'magic school' books, the magic here is a nuisance or a background detail. It subverts the genre by insisting that being a teenager is more transformative and terrifying than being a wizard.
The book is a collection of comic strips following the student body of a school for the magically gifted. Rather than epic battles, the vignettes focus on the mundane: Marsha’s secret crush on her friend Wendy, Trixie’s anxiety about her lizard-head appearance, and the immortal Everlasting Boy’s boredom with eternity. It concludes with a longer narrative arc about graduation and the bittersweet transition into adulthood.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.