This review pertains to the children's chapter book 'Tall in the Saddle' by Argentina Palacios, not the 1944 Western film of the same title. This early chapter book introduces young readers to David, a boy with a passion for horses, who encounters a significant challenge with his new horse, Acorn. Acorn is described as 'not very nice,' setting up a narrative arc focused on building trust and overcoming difficulties. The story gently explores themes of perseverance, empathy, and the rewards of patience as David works to connect with Acorn and ultimately achieve his goal of riding the horse.
The book handles the challenge of a difficult animal in a straightforward, age-appropriate manner, without introducing any overtly sensitive topics. The emotional arc is one of hopeful determination, starting with a problem and progressing towards a resolution through effort and understanding. This book is ideal for children aged 4-8 who are developing independent reading skills or for a read-aloud session with younger horse enthusiasts. A parent might reach for this book when their child is showing an interest in horses, is learning about responsibility for pets, or needs a story that models patience and resilience in the face of a challenge. No specific scenes require previewing, but parents could discuss animal behavior and the importance of gentle interaction. Younger children will enjoy the animal story and David's journey, while older children will appreciate the accessible text for independent reading practice. Its focus on the specific challenge of a 'not very nice' horse, rather than just a general love for horses, offers a slightly different angle on animal friendship stories.