About This Book
Reach for this book when your family is navigating the arrival of a new sibling, a long term houseguest, or simply a season where a child feels like a 'strange creature' who doesn't quite fit the household rules. It is a masterpiece of absurdist humor that validates the frustration and bewilderment of domestic life without being preachy. The story follows an aristocratic family as they deal with a silent, penguin like guest who moves in uninvited and stays for seventeen years. Through rhyming verse and intricate illustrations, Edward Gorey explores themes of patience, social friction, and the quiet acceptance of the inexplicable. It is a perfect choice for parents who appreciate dry wit and want to show their children that even the most 'doubtful' behaviors can eventually become part of the family fabric.
What Parents Should Know
Sensitive Topics
The book handles domestic friction and mental oddity through a strictly metaphorical lens. There is a sense of melancholy and social alienation, but it is presented with a secular, absurdist detachment. The resolution is famously ambiguous: the guest never leaves, and the family never understands him.
Ideal Reader
A child with a sophisticated or 'dark' sense of humor who enjoys Lemony Snicket or Tim Burton. It is particularly resonant for a child who feels like an outsider or who is struggling with a sibling who has behavioral challenges that disrupt the 'status quo.'
Parent Prep
Read cold. The rhyme scheme is delightful for reading aloud, but parents should be prepared for the 'non ending' which may require explaining that not every story needs a clear lesson or goodbye. A parent might reach for this after a day of feeling like their home has been hijacked by a child's inexplicable moods or after a particularly long visit from a difficult relative.
Age Experience
Younger children (4-6) focus on the funny appearance of the creature and the silly things he does. Older children (8+) and adults appreciate the satire of Victorian manners and the deeper commentary on the permanence of unwanted situations.
What Makes It Special
Unlike most children's books that resolve conflict with a hug or a lesson, this book celebrates the absurdity of living with a problem that cannot be solved, only accepted.
Discussion Prompts
1
Why do you think the family lets the guest stay even though he hides their clocks and tears up their books?
2
If the Doubtful Guest could speak, what do you think he would say about the family he is living with?
3
The book says the guest has 'no intention of going away.' How do you think the family's feelings changed from the first day to the seventeenth year?
4
Look closely at the Guest's outfit. Why do you think Edward Gorey chose to give him a scarf and sneakers instead of making him look like a wild animal?
Reviews
No reviews yet — be the first!
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a review
