
Reach for this book when your teenager is navigating the transition from casual dating to a first serious romance, or if they are grappling with feelings of inadequacy in a new relationship. Set against a lush historical backdrop, the story follows Monty and Percy as they attempt to find physical intimacy while dealing with deep-seated performance anxiety and emotional vulnerability. It is a candid look at the difference between physical confidence and the emotional bravery required to be truly known by another person. While the book contains frank discussions and scenes related to sexual intimacy, its primary focus is on consent, communication, and the realization that a partner's love is based on more than just physical attraction. It is best suited for older teens who have already read the first book in the series and are ready for a more mature exploration of queer identity and self worth.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewIncludes some historical profanity and modern mild expletives.
References to past physical and emotional abuse from a parent.
Occasional references to drinking in a historical social context.
The book deals directly with sexual identity and physical intimacy in a secular, sex-positive manner. It also touches on Monty's history of trauma (abuse from his father) and his resulting low self-esteem. The resolution is realistic and hopeful, prioritizing emotional connection over physical perfection.
An older teenager who feels like they have to put on a 'performance' to be liked. Specifically, a queer youth who may feel that their value is tied to their charm or appearance rather than their true self.
This is a 'new adult' leaning novella. Parents should be aware that it describes the lead-up to and the aftermath of sexual intimacy, though it focuses more on the emotional mechanics of consent than explicit descriptions. A parent might see their teen becoming unusually withdrawn or anxious about a new relationship, or perhaps trying too hard to be 'perfect' for a partner.
Younger teens (14) will enjoy the humor and the 'will-they-won't-they' tension. Older teens (17-18) will better appreciate the nuance of Monty's trauma and the importance of healthy communication.
Unlike many historical romances, it deconstructs the 'rakish hero' trope by showing the deep insecurity that often hides behind a confident facade.
Picking up after the events of The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue, Monty and Percy are temporarily staying on Santorini. While they are deeply in love, Monty feels immense pressure to have a perfect 'first time' with Percy. His anxiety stems from a past where he used sex as a defense mechanism, whereas he now views Percy as someone too good for him. The novella follows his failed attempts at seduction and his eventual realization that communication and patience are more important than a scripted romantic encounter.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.