
A parent might reach for this book when their clever child starts testing boundaries, using their intelligence to get their way rather than to do good. Set in 1890s Utah, this humorous story follows thirteen-year-old Tom, the 'Great Brain,' as he concocts elaborate money-making schemes, often with his younger brother J.D. as a reluctant accomplice. This installment sees Tom's plans complicated by his first crush. It's a funny, engaging way to open conversations about honesty, integrity, and the consequences of our actions. Perfect for kids 8-12, it models complex sibling dynamics and shows that being smart isn't the same as being wise.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewA thirteen-year-old boy has his first crush, which motivates some of his schemes.
The book's central theme is moral ambiguity. Tom's schemes are deceptive and manipulative, though always played for humor. There are understated references to poverty and class differences in a historical context. The approach is secular and realistic for the time period. Resolutions typically involve Tom learning a lesson, but his core conniving nature remains unchanged, offering a realistic portrayal of character development.
An 8 to 11-year-old who loves clever protagonists, funny schemes, and historical settings. It's perfect for a child who enjoys witty banter and might be starting to think about concepts like fairness, ethics, and the consequences of one's actions. Also excellent for readers who enjoy strong sibling dynamics.
No significant prep is needed, the book can be read cold. However, parents might want to be ready to discuss the ethics of Tom's schemes. Is it okay to trick people if no one gets seriously hurt? What's the difference between being smart and being deceitful? The historical context of 1890s Utah is clear but may prompt questions. The parent is concerned their child is being a bit of a 'know-it-all' or is bending the rules to get what they want. They might have heard their child say, 'But it's not technically breaking the rules!' or seen them try to outsmart a sibling or friend in a not-so-kind way.
A younger reader (8-9) will focus on the humor and cleverness of Tom's plots, seeing it as pure adventure. An older reader (10-12) is more likely to grasp the ethical dilemmas and J.D.'s role as the narrator and moral compass. They will better appreciate the nuances of Tom's character flaws and the social commentary.
Unlike stories with clear-cut 'good vs. evil' narratives, this series excels in its portrayal of a morally ambiguous protagonist. Tom is brilliant and charming but also greedy and manipulative. The humor comes from his elaborate plans backfiring, providing a gentle, non-preachy way to explore complex ethical questions through the eyes of his admiring but wary younger brother.
The story follows 13-year-old Tom Fitzgerald in 1890s Adenville, Utah. Infatuated with pretty Polly Reagan, Tom tries to win her affection and make money through a series of elaborate schemes, including a choreographed 'rescue' from a runaway wagon and selling 'petrified' human hearts he and his brother make from plaster. His younger brother, J.D., narrates the events, often acting as Tom's conscience as his plans lead to humorous but morally complex situations that inevitably get him into trouble with his parents.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.