
Reach for this book when your pre-teen starts asking big questions about their changing body, the nature of God, or why friendships suddenly feel so complicated. While it masquerades as a summer mystery, it is actually a profound exploration of the awkward transition into adolescence. It follows Harriet and her friend Beth Ellen as they investigate a series of anonymous religious notes left around their beach town. The story tackles the 'secret' of puberty, specifically menstruation, with a refreshing honesty that was decades ahead of its time. It also explores the contrast between Harriet's bold, caustic personality and Beth Ellen's quiet struggle for autonomy against a neglectful mother. It is a sharp, funny, and deeply realistic choice for children aged 9 to 13 who are beginning to outgrow the simplicity of childhood.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewHarriet's spying and judgmental notebook entries are central to her character.
The book is famous for being one of the first children's novels to mention menstruation directly. The approach is secular and matter-of-fact. It also deals with parental abandonment and social exclusion. The religious themes are handled with a critical eye, as the note-writer uses religion as a tool for judgment.
A 10 to 12 year old girl who feels like an outsider, perhaps one who finds her peers confusing or shallow, and is looking for a book that doesn't sugarcoat the realities of growing up.
Parents should be aware of the scene where the girls discuss 'the secret' (periods). It is handled well, but be prepared for follow-up questions. Harriet can also be quite mean in her notebook, which may require discussion about empathy. A parent might see their child becoming more private, start keeping a locked diary, or express sudden, intense skepticism about family traditions or religious beliefs.
Younger readers (9-10) will focus on the mystery and Harriet's funny observations. Older readers (11-13) will resonate with the themes of body changes, mother-daughter tension, and the desire for independence.
Unlike many 'coming of age' books, this one refuses to be sentimental. It captures the jagged edges of pre-teen personalities and the internal life of a 'mousy' child in a way few other books do.
Harriet and Beth Ellen are spending the summer at Water Mill. A series of anonymous, judgmental notes quoting scripture begins appearing, and Harriet, ever the detective, starts a methodical investigation. However, the mystery serves as a backdrop for deeper character studies: Harriet is dealing with her own growing pains, while Beth Ellen is facing the return of her glamorous, self-absorbed mother. The 'Long Secret' of the title refers both to the identity of the note-writer and the hush-hush nature of menstruation.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.