
Reach for this book when your teenager is struggling with the performative nature of college applications or feeling cynical about the senselessness of loss. It follows Addison Schacht, a high school senior who uses his University of Chicago application essay to process the unsolved murder of a classmate. While the story is framed as a mystery, it is truly a deep dive into teenage maladjustment and the search for authentic meaning in a world that feels increasingly hollow. The narrative explores complex grief, the ethics of drug dealing, and the blurred lines between friendship and romance. Parents should note the heavy use of profanity and drug use, as the book is a gritty, realistic look at adolescent rebellion. It is an excellent choice for facilitating honest conversations about identity, morality, and the transition to adulthood.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewConstant use of strong profanity throughout the narrative.
The inciting incident is the shooting death of a classmate.
The protagonist justifies illegal actions and challenges traditional moral frameworks.
The book deals directly and secularly with death and violence. It also features frequent drug use (marijuana), heavy profanity, and criminal activity. The resolution is realistic and somewhat ambiguous, focusing more on Addison's internal growth than a tidy legal conclusion.
An intellectually curious, somewhat rebellious high schooler who feels alienated by the 'polished' expectations of school and society. This reader likely enjoys noir tropes and anti-hero protagonists.
Parents should be aware of the constant profanity and the normalized depiction of drug dealing. It is best read with the understanding that Addison is an unreliable and flawed narrator. A parent hears their child express deep disdain for the 'fakeness' of their peers or the college application process, or discovers their child has been engaging in risky behaviors out of a sense of nihilism.
Younger teens (14) might focus on the detective elements and the 'cool' factor of rebellion, while older teens (17-18) will likely resonate with the intense pressure of transitioning to adulthood and the existential dread of the college process.
Unlike many YA mysteries that focus on the 'who-done-it,' this book is a linguistic and psychological character study that uses the mystery as a vehicle for a philosophical critique of modern youth.
Addison Schacht is a frustrated, highly intelligent senior in Washington D.C. who sells drugs to classmates and navigates a confusing relationship with his best friend, Digger. When a classmate, Kevin Broadus, is shot in what the police dismiss as gang violence, Addison becomes obsessed with finding the killer. The entire novel is framed as Addison's response to the University of Chicago's application question regarding his best and worst qualities, leading to a sprawling, cynical, and brutally honest confession.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.