
Reach for this book when your child is stuck in the 'what ifs' of grief or struggling to accept a new reality after a major loss. It is a compassionate exploration of the magnetic pull of the past and the difficult, necessary work of choosing to live in the present. Twelve year old Charlie and his younger sister Imogen discover a secret world where their mother is still alive, but they soon realize that staying in a world of memories comes at a terrifying cost. This story uses a magical 'Other World' to give physical form to abstract feelings of depression and nostalgia. It is ideal for middle grade readers who need to see that while grief is heavy, moving forward is not the same as moving on from the person they love. Parents will appreciate how it validates the desire to escape reality while ultimately celebrating the beauty of our messy, imperfect world.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe 'Other World' becomes increasingly eerie as characters begin to lose their true selves.
The backstory centers on the mother's death, which is the emotional catalyst for the plot.
The book deals directly with the death of a parent and the resulting grief. The approach is metaphorical, using a fantasy world to represent the sedentary nature of depression and the danger of living in memory. The resolution is realistic and hopeful: the mother is not resurrected, but the family finds a way to coexist with their loss.
A 10 to 12 year old who is 'parentifying' themselves after a family tragedy or a child who seems to be withdrawing into fantasy or video games to avoid the pain of a recent loss.
Read the scenes involving the 'Other Mother' to ensure your child can distinguish between the comfort of memory and the danger of the fantasy trap. The book is safe to read cold but invites deep post-chapter discussion. A parent might notice their child looking through old photos excessively, expressing a wish to 'go back in time,' or showing signs of emotional withdrawal from current family activities.
Younger readers (age 8-9) will focus on the mystery and the 'spooky' element of the disappearing photos. Older readers (11-12) will better grasp the metaphor of the Other World as a symbol for the paralysis of grief.
Unlike many grief books that focus on the immediate aftermath of death, this story brilliantly uses the 'portal fantasy' genre to examine the long-term temptation to choose the comfort of the past over the pain of the future.
Following the death of his mother, Charlie Price is struggling to hold his family together. He discovers that his younger sister, Imogen, has found a way into an 'Other World' where their mother is alive and everything is frozen in a perfect, happy past. As Imogen spends more time there, she begins to physically fade from the real world. Charlie must navigate this magical realm to bring his sister back, eventually realizing that the 'perfection' of the past is a trap that prevents them from truly living.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.