
Reach for this book when your child starts navigating the complex line between childhood imagination and the darker realities of growing up. It is a profound choice for kids who are beginning to realize that their friends might have secrets or struggles that a simple game of pretend cannot fix. This story explores the weight of keeping secrets and the terrifying possibility that the 'make-believe' worlds we create might be hiding a more grounded, painful truth. The story follows Alistair Cleary, a boy asked by his neighbor Fiona to write her biography. Fiona claims she can travel to a magical world called Aquavania, but she fears a creature called the Riverman is stealing children's stories. As Alistair investigates, he must decide if Fiona is telling a literal truth or if her stories are a metaphor for something dangerous in their real town. This is a sophisticated, slightly dark mystery for middle schoolers that explores trust, loyalty, and the loss of innocence.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThe ending is ambiguous and challenges the reader to decide what was real.
Children are in danger from both supernatural and potentially real-world threats.
Themes of lost childhood, trauma, and the disappearance of a friend.
The book deals with the potential of child grooming and abduction. The approach is highly metaphorical and atmospheric, leaving the nature of the 'Riverman' open to interpretation for much of the book. The resolution is realistic and somewhat haunting, lacking a traditional 'happily ever after' in favor of emotional depth.
A thoughtful 12-year-old who enjoys 'Stranger Things' but wants something more introspective. It is for the child who is outgrowing fairy tales but still feels their pull, and who is starting to understand that adults can be dangerous.
Parents should preview the final third of the book. The ending suggests that the Riverman may represent a real neighborhood predator, which could be upsetting without discussion. A child may express fear that a friend is being hurt or mention that someone 'made them promise not to tell.'
Younger readers (10-11) may focus on the fantasy elements of Aquavania. Older readers (13-14) will likely pick up on the subtext regarding trauma and the way stories are used to process pain.
Unlike most middle-grade fantasy, this book questions the safety of 'portal' worlds. It treats imagination not just as a gift, but as a potential refuge from a reality that the protagonist isn't yet ready to face.
Alistair Cleary is a logic-minded boy in 1989 upstate New York. His neighbor, Fiona Loomis, reveals she has found a portal to Aquavania, a world where children's imaginations come to life. However, she claims the Riverman is stealing the souls of children there. Alistair must determine if Fiona is experiencing a fantasy adventure, a mental health crisis, or if she is a victim of a real-world predator using stories as a shield.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.