
Reach for this book when your family is grappling with a loved one's substance use disorder or when your child is feeling the heavy weight of a secret they cannot fix. The story follows twelve year old Charlie, who discovers a magical, wish granting fish while ice fishing. While her initial wishes are for small things like dance success, the stakes skyrocket when she discovers her older sister is addicted to heroin. This novel masterfully bridges the gap between childhood wonder and the harsh realities of the opioid crisis, offering a lifeline of empathy for middle grade readers. It is an essential choice for parents looking to validate a child's feelings of helplessness, shame, and love in the face of family illness. Messner handles the subject with profound grace, ensuring the magic never trivializes the very real struggle of addiction.
Your experience helps other parents find the right book.
Sign in to write a reviewThemes of family secrets, betrayal of trust, and the fear of losing a sibling.
A tense scene involving an overdose and emergency medical intervention.
Some tension regarding ice fishing safety and the consequences of the fish's wishes.
The book deals directly and realistically with heroin addiction and overdose. The approach is secular and medical, framing addiction as a chronic illness rather than a moral failure. The resolution is realistic: Abby enters rehab, and while there is hope, there is no magical 'cure.'
A middle-schooler (ages 10 to 13) who feels responsible for 'saving' someone in their family or a child who is witnessing the confusing changes that come with a sibling's substance abuse.
Parents should be aware of a scene involving a non-fatal overdose and the use of Narcan. It is best to read this alongside the child or be ready for questions about what 'rehab' actually looks like. A parent might see their child withdrawing, becoming hyper-focused on their own achievements to compensate for a sibling's trouble, or expressing 'wishes' that things could go back to the way they were.
Younger readers (10) will focus on the magic and the fear for the sister's safety. Older readers (13-14) will better grasp the nuance of the 'wish' metaphor and the social pressures Charlie faces.
Unlike many books on addiction, this one uses the 'monkey's paw' trope of magical wishing to highlight the specific feeling of powerlessness that children feel when a loved one is suffering.
Charlie is a 12-year-old obsessed with Irish step dancing and ice fishing. When she catches a magical flourback fluke that grants wishes, she thinks she can nudge her life toward perfection. However, the whimsical tone shifts when Charlie realizes her college-age sister, Abby, is addicted to heroin. As Abby's situation worsens, Charlie tries to use her wishes to 'fix' her sister, eventually learning that addiction is a complex disease that magic cannot simply wash away.
This overview was generated by AI based on the book's content and reviews, and may not capture every nuance.