The Witch Lady Mystery

A parent might reach for this book when their child is quick to believe rumors or has formed a negative first impression of someone who seems different. It’s an ideal story to gently challenge black-and-white thinking and encourage looking closer. The book follows sisters Hester and Alice, who have just moved to a new neighborhood. They become convinced that their reclusive elderly neighbor, Mrs. Tuggle, is a witch. Their summer project becomes spying on her to gather proof. Instead of magic, they uncover a story of loneliness and misunderstanding, leading them to replace their fear with empathy and friendship. This quiet, classic mystery is perfect for ages 8-10. It’s a wonderful tool for starting conversations about judging others, the power of kindness, and the courage it takes to question what everyone else believes.