The Witch of Godstow Abbey, the second installment in the "Murders in the Abbey" series, offers a compelling blend of historical mystery, supernatural intrigue, and adventure. The narrative centers on a widowed academic who finds herself transported to 1299 Oxford, where she joins forces with a group of nuns and other allies. Together, they confront a sinister secret society responsible for murders and plotting to sacrifice a young woman and seize control of the convent. The book directly addresses themes of good versus evil, loyalty, and the pursuit of justice, set against a vividly depicted medieval backdrop.
The emotional arc is one of escalating suspense and danger, with moments of hope and triumph as the protagonists fight for what is right. It's a book for readers who are drawn to intricate plots, strong character development, and a clear moral struggle. Parents will find this suitable for children who have outgrown simpler mysteries and are ready for more complex narratives with higher stakes. It's an excellent choice for a child looking for a "page-turner" that combines historical facts with a fantastical, spine-tingling element.
Parents should be prepared to discuss the prominent themes of violence, peril, and occult practices. While the time travel is described as a "dream state," the threats faced by the characters are very real and intense. Younger middle-grade readers (ages 10-11) might find some scenes quite scary, while older middle-grade readers (12-14) will likely appreciate the nuanced plot, historical details, and the bravery of the characters more deeply. What sets this book apart is its unique combination of a medieval monastic setting, a modern academic protagonist, and the overt supernatural elements woven into a fast-paced murder mystery.
